StubHub FanProtect guarantee failed. Here’s how one buyer fought back.

When Jeff Balesh buys tickets to see Eric Clapton in Philadelphia, he counts on StubHub’s FanProtect Guarantee to protect his purchase. It fails. Now, with travel booked and a 24th anniversary on the line, he needs StubHub to honor its promise.

Question

I bought two tickets to an Eric Clapton concert in Philadelphia through StubHub a few months ago. The seats were in Section 114, and I paid $780, including over $100 in service fees, because I wanted the protection of StubHub’s FanProtect Guarantee. That guarantee promises buyers the exact tickets they ordered — or comparable or better replacement seats.

But the seller backed out of the deal. StubHub canceled my purchase and offered replacement seats in Section 108 or 207 — dramatically inferior to what I paid for. 

I wrote to StubHub’s customer service team and even copied several executives, but I was told “the system” had given me what it could offer and nothing more.

This was supposed to be a special anniversary gift for my wife, and we’ve already booked travel and a hotel in Philadelphia. A refund is not acceptable. I just want StubHub to honor its promise and provide tickets in Section 114, 124, or floor sections. Can you help? — Jeff Balesh, Towson, Md.

Answer

StubHub’s FanProtect Guarantee is clear: If your seller cancels, the company promises replacement tickets that are the same or comparable to those you originally booked. But there’s a significant asterisk buried in that guarantee, and I’ll get to it in a moment.

Your paper trail shows you did everything right. You contacted customer service, asked for help on social media, and escalated your complaint to the executive level. (I publish the names, numbers and email addresses of the StubHub executive contacts on my consumer advocacy site, Elliott Advocacy.)

StubHub still wouldn’t budge. Instead, it told you that its system dictated the replacement tickets, even though you could see better seats available on its own site. That’s the kind of corporate doublespeak that makes consumers feel cheated and disrespected. Kind of like something right out of an Eric Clapton song, come to think of it. (Related: Ticketmaster sold me “great seats” that turned out to be obstructed. Where’s my refund?)

You were also right to push back against a refund, which was your other option. But remember that asterisk I was talking about? Here it is: According to the guarantee, StubHub will “find you comparable or better tickets to the event, or offer you a refund of what you paid for your purchase or credit of the same amount for use on a future purchase.” In other words, under the guarantee, StubHub could offer you a refund and it would be in compliance.

Why StubHub’s FanProtect guarantee has a major catch

Quick sidebar: Our advocacy team has been receiving a growing number of StubHub complaints lately, many involving the FanProtect Guarantee. If StubHub is going to advertise that it protects ticket buyers, it needs to make good on that promise — or change the way it promotes its guarantee. There’s no two ways about it. (Related: StubHub charged me $3,300 for Coldplay tickets I never received — can I get my money back?)

Your case shows why persistence matters. When a company makes a bold promise like StubHub’s FanProtect, customers should expect it to follow through. If it isn’t, don’t accept excuses about what the “system” can or can’t do. Press for the resolution you’re owed.

I reached out to StubHub on your behalf. After some back-and-forth, the company finally honored its guarantee. It issued you tickets in the same section you originally booked, just as you asked. You and your wife will celebrate your 24th anniversary at an Eric Clapton concert after all.