UPS kept my $400 after damaging my computer — can it do that?

Photo of author

By Christopher Elliott

In This Case – UPS Claim Denial

in this case

  • Vaughn Warriner shipped his old 27″ iMac to his granddaughter through the UPS Store. He paid $53 for shipping and bought $400 of declared value coverage. UPS lost the computer.
  • UPS asked for the serial number, proof of value, and the original Apple purchase receipt from 2015. Then it asked for the serial number again. Then proof of value again. Then the Apple receipt again. Then the serial number again. Then it asked him to upload everything again.
  • Warriner spent hours on phone and online chat with UPS and got nowhere. He tried contacting UPS executives with no response. After five months of back and forth, UPS still refused to pay the $400 claim.

Vaughn Warriner’s Apple computer gets damaged in transit when he sends it his granddaughter. Now UPS is refusing his $400 claim. Can it do that?

Question

I shipped my old 27” iMac to my granddaughter through the UPS Store. UPS lost it.

I had purchased $400 of declared value coverage and paid $53 for shipping. UPS told me to file a claim directly online which I did.

UPS asked for the serial number, proof of value, and even the original Apple purchase receipt from 2015. I provided all of it.

UPS then asked for the serial number. Then it asked for proof of value. Then it asked me for the original Apple purchase receipt from 2015. Finally, UPS asked me to provide the serial number of the computer. I provided all of it.

Then it asked me to upload everything again. The UPS site is confusing and seems designed to make me give up. Top Comment – Gerri Hether

🏆 Your top comment

Companies request so much documentation in the hopes that the consumer will not have it to provide, and when it is they simply ignore it, hoping the consumer simply goes away.

– Gerri Hether
Read more insightful reader feedback. See all comments.

I spent hours on the phone and online chat with UPS and got nowhere. I’ve tried contacting the UPS executives on your site, but they have not responded. After five months of back and forth, UPS still refused to pay. Can you help me recover my money? — Vaughn Warriner, Irvine, Calif.

Global Rescue is the world’s leading provider of medical, security, evacuation and travel risk management services. Founded in 2004, Global Rescue has exclusive relationships with the Johns Hopkins Emergency Medicine Division of Special Operations and Elite Medical Group. Global Rescue provides best-in-class services that identify, monitor and respond to client medical and security crises. Learn more about Global Rescue.

Answer

You bought UPS’ “declared value coverage,” which is UPS’ maximum liability if a package is lost or damaged. In theory, it’s supposed to reimburse you for the item’s actual worth, up to the declared value.

In practice, as you discovered, UPS makes the process so bureaucratic that many customers walk away. It demands serial numbers, receipts, invoices, and repeated uploads. (Related: Let’s sink these antiquated shipping laws for good.)

UPS should have offered a way to file your claim quickly, and only once. I’ve seen this kind of thing before, and you’re absolutely right, the bureaucracy makes it look like they’re trying to make you give up. But you didn’t.

You did everything right: you saved the box, kept receipts, and even dug up a 10-year-old Apple invoice. Reaching out to a UPS executive should have worked. I list the names, numbers and emails of the UPS executives on my consumer advocacy site, Elliott.org.

Your case is a reminder of two things. First, if you declare a value, be prepared to prove it with receipts, serial numbers, and documentation. Second, persistence pays. UPS’ claim system may be confusing by design, but if you keep pushing — and bring in a consumer advocate when necessary — you can get what you paid for.

When I contacted UPS, it reviewed your case and agreed to pay $453 — the $400 declared value plus $53 for shipping. Your Voice Matters – UPS Claim Denial

Your voice matters

Vaughn Warriner paid $53 to ship his iMac and bought $400 declared value coverage. UPS lost the computer, then asked for the same documents repeatedly and made him upload everything multiple times. After five months, UPS still refused to pay.

  • Should shipping companies be required to process declared value claims within 30 days when customers provide all requested documentation?
  • Should shipping companies be prohibited from asking for the same documents multiple times in a single claim?
  • Should declared value coverage come with automatic penalties when companies drag out claims beyond reasonable timeframes?
49514
Should shipping companies face automatic financial penalties when they delay declared value claims beyond 30 days?
What You’re Saying – UPS Claim Denial

What you’re saying

Readers called out the bureaucracy as deliberate, suggested triple damages for delayed claims, and shared similar experiences with shipping companies and the post office.

  • Keep every receipt

    M.C. Storm said this is why he files and keeps every receipt and guarantee. You will need it eventually. Mandy pointed out even the original 2015 Apple receipt was provided, so this should have been a smooth claim, not a months-long fight.

  • Triple damages for delayed claims

    Insightful Cowbell suggested shipping companies should pay triple damages if they don’t honor purchased insurance within 45 days when documentation is provided. EricLG said asking for documentation already provided should trigger a penalty as well. It’s an admission of incompetence and contempt for consumers.

  • AI failure or deliberate design?

    Tim said this sounds like an AI failure rather than deliberately programming AI to frustrate consumers. He wondered if companies like UPS realize how poorly AI works. SusanV said that doesn’t explain the lack of response from executives he emailed. Yvonne West shared she had the same problem with the post office and insured gift cards, eventually filing a complaint with the Postmaster General that started an investigation.

Photo of author

Christopher Elliott

Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that empowers consumers to solve their problems and helps those who can't. He's the author of numerous books on consumer advocacy and writes three nationally syndicated columns. He also publishes the Elliott Report, a news site for consumers, and Elliott Confidential, a critically acclaimed newsletter about customer service. If you have a consumer problem you can't solve, contact him directly through his advocacy website. You can also follow him on X, Facebook, and LinkedIn, or sign up for his daily newsletter.

Related Posts