Is this enough compensation? A flight voucher for damaged luggage

When Rose Satz showed up at the luggage carousel in Baltimore after a recent American Airlines flight from Dallas, she found her almost-new American Tourister bag in bad shape. It had been scuffed, the zipper was busted and several items were missing from it, including her dental retainer and expensive makeup.

Satz immediately found an American Airlines representative and asked him what to do. He suggested she contact baggage services when she gets home, which in retrospect was the wrong advice. Always, always, always file a claim at the airport.

You know what comes next, don’t you? Here’s the final answer to her claim:

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Mediacom Communications. The nation’s fifth-largest cable operator, serving the smaller cities and towns in the Midwest and Southern regions of the United States. We are a high-performance broadband, entertainment, and communications company that brings the power of modern technology and quality customer experience to life inside the connected home by combining ultra-fast gigabit speeds with personalized local and over-the-top entertainment choices that fit your lifestyle. Details at

Thank you for your recent letter concerning our decision on your claim for missing property. I have reviewed your file and regret the disappointment created by our decision. While I can understand your feelings, I appreciate this opportunity to explain our decision.

As stated earlier, missing property must be reported within 24 hours and claims must be made in writing within 45 days following the loss in order to be considered for compensation. This time frame is necessary as prompt notification provides the best probability of recovery.

Since records show our Baggage Service Office was open at the time your flight arrived and we have no record of notification until 24 hours past the travel date, our decision will remain unchanged.

Actually, that’s not all the airline’s records show. Satz flew on American, but for reasons that aren’t entirely clear, she filed a lost luggage claim with United. Of course United didn’t have a record of her filing a claim. It didn’t have a record of her flying at all.

I might laugh at this, but I’m not one to talk. A few days ago I tried to check in at the wrong hotel. Seriously. After arguing for a few minutes with a front-desk employee, I finally consulted my itinerary and realized I was at the wrong place. Oops!

I suggested Satz send a brief, polite note to a manager at American, asking it to address her lost luggage. Under normal circumstances, the airline would compensate her for lost or damaged items by cutting her a check. But this was a different situation.

Last week, she heard back from American. It offered her a $300 voucher for her trouble, which she’s sort of happy with. But she’s still upset by the experience.

I have reasons to believe that these airlines are taking advantage of us by not clearly explaining the procedures to us. I felt both discouraged and misinformed by the baggage claim representative at BWI.

In our correspondence, American addresses me as “Mr.” Rose Satz. This is a clearly indication that they just don’t care.

Perhaps. But a $300 voucher for a long-delayed claim is not a bad offer. Satz could have ended up with nothing more than an empty apology.

But is it enough?