Someone just did something about the ‘stranglehold’ on airline competition

Yesterday, my colleague Kendall Creighton asked if the big three airlines have a “stranglehold” on three New York area airports.

She noted that Virgin America, Frontier Airlines, Allegiant Air, Spirit Airlines and Alaska Airlines sent a letter to the Federal Aviation Administration and the US Department of Transportation, complaining about the “vise grip” on hundreds of takeoff and landing slots in New York.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Chubb. Chubb is the world’s largest publicly traded property and casualty insurance company, and recognized as the premier provider of insurance for successful individuals and families in the U.S. and selected international markets, offering coverage for high-value automobile, homeowners, recreational marine/aviation, valuables and umbrella liability coverage. As an underwriting company, Chubb assesses, assumes and manages risk with insight and discipline, and combines the precision of craftsmanship with decades of experience to conceive, craft and deliver the best insurance coverage and services to individuals, families and business of all size.

And guess what? Only an hour after her story posted, the Department of Justice (DOJ) announced it had filed an antitrust lawsuit against United Airlines to block its monopolization of slots in Newark.

Well, color me impressed.

“A slot is essentially a license to compete at Newark,” Assistant Attorney General Bill Baer of the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division said in a prepared statement. “United already holds most of them, and as a result, competition at Newark is in critically short supply.”

The DOJ alleges United is extracting what it calls a “Newark premium.” Airfares at Newark are among the highest in the country, while United’s service at Newark ranks among the worst.

Allowing United to acquire even more slots at Newark would “fortify United’s monopoly position, and weaken rivals’ ability to challenge that dominance, leaving consumers to pay the price,” Baer added.

Consumer groups approved of the actions.

“This is an important day for business travelers who have been on the losing end of the big three U.S. carriers’ stranglehold at Newark, where they control 91 percent of the slots and charge some of the highest fares in the country,” said Kevin Mitchell, founder of the Business Travel Coalition. DOJ no doubt has viewed with alarm the behavior of the big three in a radically consolidated industry.”

Added Charles Leocha of Travelers United, another consumer group, “This is not a level playing field, nor is there effective competition.”

The control of airline traffic in and out of LaGuardia, JFK and Newark Airports in the New York area is dramatic. Delta and American Airlines slots at LaGuardia dwarf those of other competitors. American, Delta and jetBlue control more than 90 percent of the slots at JFK. And, United holds 902 of 1,233 available slots at Newark, he says.

“The control of airport takeoff and landing slots and the careful shuffling of these controlled slots among the major carriers amounts to restraint of trade, and clearly falls under the antitrust laws enforced by DOJ,” he adds.

Don’t get too excited. Remember, the DOJ’s Bill Baer also called for a “full stop” of the merger between American and US Airways, and we all know where that got us.

I’m sure we’ll be hearing from the laissez-faire capitalists and free marketers in coming days, who will say this is government interference of the highest order. But as a consumer advocate, I don’t think the government is going far enough. It should be giving these slots to startups which will bring real competition to New York, not ceding it to those who would throttle free enterprise.

Will the DOJ restore competition to New York?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

6 thoughts on “Someone just did something about the ‘stranglehold’ on airline competition

  1. I voted Yes and I hope it isn’t just wishful thinking. Working in Clinical Research (I swear every flight in the country, and a good number of them OUS, has passengers on it for this reason), I can easily attest to how high the fares are out of Newark. It is totally ridiculous that a fare from Newark to CA might be twice what it is to fly from Logan to CA. Especially to those destinations on the “second tier”. So fares from Newark might be 25-40% higher to LAX, but can be as much as 50-100% higher going to Fresno. It is even significantly less to fly out of Kennedy or LaGuardia than Newark.

  2. As one of those “laissez-faire capitalists”, I would like to see more competition among air carriers, but I can’t imagine how it might be brought about unless there is a rotation of some sort: eenie-meenie-miney-mo, Joe’s Airline, do you want this slot? No? Okay, Fred’s Airline? No? Okay, Delta? SOLD! Next slot is….

  3. So Chris, does your picture of advocacy extend to getting involved at the governmental or regulatory level? Petitions perhaps? Under the idea of ‘countervailing power’, there doesn’t seem to be much in the way of groups or organizations that effectively advocate for consumers to balance out the pernicious influence of lobbyist$ and other form$ of corporate influence. You know, with a little tweak to your polls, they could become petitions…

  4. I have nothing against an airline “owning” slots at an airport. But they need to be actively using those slots and not keeping them in reserve just in case they need them. I feel the action by the government was proper in this case.

  5. My Solution: Each Slot (Pair) would be auctioned by the FAA with a 10 year Life, 10% coming up for bid each year. Slots would be use it or lose it, If your slot(s) is inactive for more then X months, The slot returns to the pool and get re-sold (no refunds for the unused life in it) at the next auction period, for the life left on it. Slots could only be sold to FAA certified Domestic/International carriers, and the FBO/Part 91/135’s, Speculation buying of slots would not be permitted. Owners of Slots could re-sell unneeded the slots at the next auction period, With the FAA keeping a Small percent for administrating the sale(s). (Maybe 10%).

  6. Which airline are you looking at? On Delta I can often find cheaper fares out of Newark than out of LGA or JFK.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: