Could asking for an upgrade to business class cause you to get kicked off your flight — and banned for life?
It seems so.
“Social Influencer” Jacqueline Ng insists that’s exactly what happened to her when she recently asked for an upgrade. Cathay Pacific agents turned down her request in no time and then kicked her off the flight. Worse, the airline accused her of fraud and banned her from all future flights.
Ng says this is all a misunderstanding. Now she wants the Elliott Advocacy team to investigate and ask the airline to reverse the banishment.
This case provides a warning to all passengers looking for creative ways to score an airline upgrade. If you’re not careful, these requests can backfire — spectacularly — and you could even wind up being removed from your flight, too.
Asking for an upgrade on a very long flight
Ng says that her shocking dilemma began in May during a round-trip journey from Taiwan to New York. She purchased a premium economy ticket and then decided to ask for an upgrade to business class.
Before boarding the initial Taiwan to JFK flight, I filled out an online form. I emailed Cathay Pacific to try and upgrade to business class on both my outbound and return. I received an email confirming that I was eligible for a business class seat. The email from Cathay Pacific clearly stated the upgrade was only possible, if available.
When Ng arrived at the check-in counter for the flight to JFK, she asked about the upgrade. She gave the agent a copy of the Cathay Pacific email indicating her eligibility for a move into business class. Unfortunately, the agent explained, the airline would be unable to upgrade her on the long flight. Ng flew to New York in her premium economy seat without incident.
But the wheels had already been set into motion for the awful eventuality.
Surprise! You’re kicked off the flight
Ng checked in for her return flight the night before its scheduled departure. She printed out her premium economy boarding pass with no problem. But when she arrived at the airport, she once again asked for an upgrade to business class. Ng showed the agent the email from Cathay Pacific customer service claiming she was eligible for the upgrade.
This time, the agent took a look at the letter and called for his supervisor. This representative walked away from the counter for some time before returning with a startling announcement.
“[The supervisor] proceeded to give me a ‘refusal of carriage letter’ 30 minutes later,” Ng recalled. “He stated that security said that Cathay Pacific did not send that email and that I had committed fraud.”
Standing at the counter in disbelief, Ng says she couldn’t believe the absurdity of the accusations. She had only asked for an upgrade, but now she was being kicked off the flight — with no way home. She tried to reason with the supervisor; however, she quickly realized the decision wasn’t negotiable.
Dumbfounded and embarrassed, Ng made arrangements on another airline and headed home. On the long flight, she had plenty of time to mull over the shocking turn of events.
Accused of presenting fraudulent documents to ask for an upgrade
Initially, Ng believed that she would easily be able to clear up this “misunderstanding.”
Following much of the helpful advice that Christopher Elliott offers in his self-advocacy guide, Ng composed a short, polite email. She sent a request to both Cathay Pacific and its parent company, Swire. She wanted the airline to refund the flight it forced her to buy when the agents denied her boarding in New York.
Several weeks later, a Cathay Pacific executive sent an official response to Ng. In that letter, the executive explains that the airline’s security department determined that the email Ng had presented to ask for the upgrade was fraudulent. It had not originated from Cathay Pacific. However, if Ng could provide the embedded information from the email to show from where it came, the airline’s team would be happy to review this evidence.
Dear Ms Ng
In the case that you are certain of the authenticity of your emails, please facilitate our further investigation by sending us:
1. A copy of the email you sent to us prior to boarding of your flight on 07 June 2019 as mentioned in your email to Swire on 27 June 2019;
2. *The “.eml” document of the two upgrade emails you received from us. You may follow the steps as detailed in the attached document;
3. Any other supporting information. (Cathay Pacific)
*The “eml” version of the email would provide the electronic metadata of the document — the details of exactly where the email originated.
All further communication must go through my legal counsel
In response to this email, Ng made a crucial mistake in her self-advocacy mission. Not only did she not provide the requested information, she told the executive that she failed to see “the relevance of this request.” Then she announced that all further communication should go through her own legal counsel.
Cathay Pacific appeared more than happy to comply with Ng’s instructions. The executive team sent another, more to the point accusation.
On 30 May 2019 and 07 June 2019 when you checked in at our Taipei and New York airport counters respectively. You presented two different emails with the same reference number, asking for upgrades on flights CX495 and CX890 on 30 May 2019 and flight CX865 on 07 June 2019. The offers were made to you by R**** L*** according to the emails you showed our check-in staff.
We verified with R**** and understand that he did not send any such emails to you. We also cross-checked our email systems and confirmed no emails were delivered to you on the date and time as indicated in your emails.
To the best of our knowledge with the information on hand, we concluded that the emails you presented for upgrades were not issued by Cathay Pacific Airways. The decision was made to refuse the carriage of you given your repeated attempts to present a fraudulent document for upgrading on our flights.
The email string ended with the Cathay Pacific team saying it would await any further communication from Ng’s “legal counsel.”
We can understand and respect your decision that you [don’t want] to further communicate with us unless it’s through your legal counsel. Please have your legal counsel write to us through this email address with the same subject line. I will turn over your case to our legal team for a direct follow up with your legal counsel. (Cathay Pacific)
Unfortunately, Ng didn’t have any legal counsel — it was an empty threat, and the airline had called her bluff.
Asking the Elliott Advocacy team for help
When I read through Ng’s request for help, I was highly doubtful that Cathay Pacific would respond to my inquiries. We know that once a consumer threatens legal action, most companies send the case to their own legal departments. The regular channels that companies offer us for mediation typically close at that point.
But I went through all of the other documentation that Ng provided. She was still under the impression that if only the airline took a look at her upstanding character, their team would realize she is no security threat. In fact, she pointed out that she had initially moved to Asia to work for Swire (the parent company of Cathay Pacific).
I moved to Hong Kong to work for Swire Resources as a Brand Manager in June 2018. I resigned from the role in November 2018 on my own self-accord. You can see that both my employee profile and reviews were extremely stellar and I received strong recommendations from my Director/HR. You can Google my background to also see that back in Canada; I won the Top 20 Under 20 National Award, given to young Canadians who have shown innovation, leadership, and achievement in society. The above speaks to my character.
But despite this glowing review, it was clear from the paper trail that Cathay Pacific had determined that the document Ng produced on two occasions to ask for an upgrade was fraudulent.
Did a social influencer present a fraudulent document to ask for an upgrade?
I asked Ng to send me a copy of the upgrade eligibility document. And that’s where things got a little weird.
What is a “social media influencer” anyway?
Nowhere in any of Ng’s correspondence with the airline or with me until that point did she mention anything about being a social media influencer. But in the email that Cathay Pacific says is a fraud, it’s clear she’s presented herself as an influencer to request an upgrade.
In case you’ve never heard the term, a social media influencer is someone who has a strong social media following — usually on YouTube or Instagram. In exchange for mentioning a product or company on their social media feed, businesses will offer freebies to the “influencer.”
I asked Ng if she had portrayed herself as a social media influencer to ask for the upgrade. She didn’t answer that question but continued to reiterate that Cathay Pacific had wrongly kicked her off the flight. When I pointed out that her case is in the legal department and so had escalated beyond where a consumer advocacy team can help, she expressed surprise.
How is [my case] escalated to the Cathay legal department when this is my first time ever having any flight issues of any kind with Cathay. And to top it all off, [I didn’t gain anything] in the situation? [Cathay Pacific never issued an upgrade].
Unfortunately, the executive team had already explained to her that it didn’t matter if she had ultimately benefited from the questionable email. Their decision remained the same.
Asking Cathay Pacific about this unusual upgrade request
I decided to send Ng’s case over to the executives at Cathay Pacific. I hoped to provide some closure for Ng. Based on the lengthy paper trail from the airline, it seemed clear that their team had conducted an extensive investigation.
Surprisingly, I soon heard back from the corporate communications department of Cathay Pacific.
Thanks for reaching out. We reviewed the case in question thoroughly. We certainly do not take any decisions we make with regards to our customers lightly; however, we do not comment on individual cases. (Cathay Pacific Corporate Communications)
Cathay Pacific does not intend to reverse its decision
And so, I broke the bad news to Ng that the airline doesn’t intend to reverse its decision. I suggested that if she could provide the metadata of the upgrade eligibility email, she may be able to prove it came from Cathay Pacific. So far she’s not been able to gather that information and she remains banned from the airline – just like Marko Kasic earlier this summer. He also got kicked off a flight and then banished from an airline forever:
Travelers should be aware that airlines seem more willing than ever to put their (former) passengers on the blacklist.
In Ng’s case, Cathay Pacific refunded the unused segment for the flight she was kicked off of. But it has declined her $1,400 request for reimbursement for the new flight. This is in accordance with the terms and conditions of Cathay Pacific.
We will not be liable for any consequential loss or damage alleged due to any such refusal to carry or removal en route. (Cathay Pacific contract of carriage — sec. 8.2)
Ng says she intends to hire that legal counsel she referenced earlier in her plight. She’s hopeful that an attorney can prove that she isn’t guilty of creating fake documents to score an upgrade — and that the airline kicked her off the flight in error.
How to ask correctly ask for an upgrade (and not get kicked off the flight in the process)
The fact is, no matter what you read, free or spontaneous airline upgrades are almost impossible to snag. The airlines typically dole those upgrades out to upper tiered frequent flyers in an automated fashion. There is a trickle-down effect to the lower-tiered frequent flyers if the business class seats remain unoccupied closer to the flight. The airlines make almost no upgrades available to infrequent travelers or passengers not willing to pay for the upgrade.
But here’s how you might end up in an upgraded seat on your next flight:
- Put yourself on the waitlist for an upgrade:
As I mentioned a bit earlier, most airline upgrades are automatically granted by computer algorithms today. You’ll need to put yourself on the waitlist for your flight if you hope for an upgrade. Then you’ll receive an alert when and if the upgrade clears. *Make sure to confirm the cost of the upgrade before you put yourself on the waitlist. The airline will automatically charge your credit card when it approves you for the upgrade.
- Sign up for the airline’s frequent flyer program:
To be able to go on a waitlist for a possible upgrade, you must belong to the airline’s frequent flyer program. These programs are free to join, and you can earn miles toward free flights and the miles you earn can also pay for those upgrades.
- Bid on an upgrade:
Increasingly, airlines are turning to online upgrade auctions to sell their available business class seats. This is especially true in the international market. But the bidding process can be tricky for non-computer savvy travelers. It’s imperative to make sure you understand the bidding system before you dive in. Our team has received quite a few pleas for help from bewildered passengers who ended up mistakenly bidding much more for their flight upgrade than they expected to pay. Proceed with caution if you want to try to win a low-cost upgrade.
- Pay for the upgrade:
The dynamic pricing of airline tickets also applies to upgrades. As it gets closer to the date of departure, if that algorithm has determined that the airline should lower the cost of the upgrade, it will do so. Many airlines offer the option to purchase the upgrade through your online account. But make sure you’re willing to pay the price if you accept the upgrade — no airline will refund a business class seat after you fly in it. (See: This United business class upgrade wasn’t worth $999. I want my money back!)
- Don’t purchase basic economy tickets:
These tickets aren’t upgradable. So don’t bother asking for an upgrade if you’ve purchased the lowest fare class — it’s not going to happen.
- Ask for an upgrade at check-in:
Extremely rarely, depending on the market, there might be unsold seats available at check-in. If you’re polite, friendly, dressed nicely and well-groomed, you might be able to charm your way into an upgrade. You’ll have the best chance of this scheme working if you’re flying solo. Good luck — you’re going to need it. 🙂 (Michelle Couch-Friedman, Elliott Advocacy)