A hurricane ruined his St. Thomas honeymoon. Now American Airlines is keeping his money

A missed honeymoon and a $200 American Airlines change fee.

When a hurricane ruins Evan Hasara’s honeymoon, he’s stuck with a $200 American Airlines cancellation fee. Can he get a refund from Travelocity or American Airlines? Does he even deserve one?


I had to cancel my honeymoon trip to Sugar Bay Resort and Spa in St. Thomas a few days before my departure in October because of Hurricane Irma.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Fareportal. Fareportal’s portfolio of brands, which include  CheapOair and  OneTravel, are dedicated to helping customers enjoy their trip. Whether you want to call, click, or use one of our travel apps, one thing is clear: We make it easy to take it easy.

I had booked the package through Travelocity. It included roundtrip airfare and hotel. But the hurricane damaged the resort and it won’t be open until sometime in 2018. I received my full refund for the hotel, but I was hit with a $200 American Airlines cancellation fee.

The tickets are supposed to be refundable. I’ve been trying to get a refund on the cancellation fee, but Travelocity says there’s nothing it can do and American refuses. Can you help me get my $400 back? — Evan Hasara, Milwaukee, Wis.


Congratulations on getting hitched. I’m sorry about the timing. Last year’s hyperactive hurricane season ruined so many vacations, including yours, unfortunately. Travelocity should have helped you secure a full refund for your honeymoon. And if it couldn’t, then American Airlines should have stepped up and done the right thing. I mean, come on. It’s your honeymoon!

But let’s talk about that for a second. You booked your special vacation through an online travel agency. That’s fine if you’re taking a quick getaway, but doesn’t your honeymoon deserve the white-glove treatment that only a personal travel advisor can deliver? You can find a list of qualified agents on the American Society of Travel Agents site.

A $200 American Airlines cancellation fee even after a hurricane? 

Still, Travelocity should have taken care of you. “For every step of the journey,” the site promises, “we’re here.” Specifically, Travelocity assures you that in the event of a weather threat or mass disruption, “We’ll work with our travel partners to make any necessary itinerary changes at the most reasonable cost to you.” And a $200 American Airlines cancellation fee is definitely not reasonable under the circumstances.

I reviewed your paperwork, and it appears you were flying on a special ticket that could be changed, if necessary. My Travelocity contact read the fare rules differently, leaving little hope for you to get a refund.

A brief, polite appeal to one of the customer service executives might have helped. I list the names, numbers and email addresses for both Travelocity (owned by Expedia) and American Airlines on my consumer advocacy site.

I contacted American Airlines on your behalf, and it refunded your cancellation fees.