Liar, liar! 28 percent of hotel guests admit they stretched the truth for a discount

If you’ve ever fudged a few facts to get a hotel discount, you’re not alone. Almost 3 in 10 hotel guests admit they stretched the truth to save a few bucks, according to a new survey.

Asked if they’d ever lied to secure a discount, 28 percent said “yes.” A majority — 72 percent — said they’d never misstated a few facts in order to save money.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Global Rescue -- Global Rescue is the world’s leading provider of medical, security, evacuation and travel risk management services. Founded in 2004, Global Rescue has exclusive relationships with the Johns Hopkins Emergency Medicine Division of Special Operations and Elite Medical Group. Global Rescue provides best-in-class services that identify, monitor and respond to client medical and security crises. Learn more about Global Rescue.

The survey of more than 800 travelers was conducted last week by readers of this site, Consumer Traveler and members of the Consumer Travel Alliance.

Although the number of hotel guests who say they’ve lied may seem high, it mirrors similar surveys conducted in the past. (I’ve dealt with the subject of guest honesty in previous columns, including this memorable story.)

Of course, not everyone can agree on a definition of lying.

Tom Vickers admits he’s claimed a AAA discount, even when his membership is out of date. Is that lying? Technically, yes. But it’s something a lot of guests — including me — have done a time or two.

“My logic is that utilizing this rate hurts neither the hotel or AAA,” he says. “No money changes hands between them because of my stay. Most of the time, the discount rate is accepted without a requirement to show a card.”

(My excuse is that I intended to renew my AAA membership, which I inevitably do, despite my occasional complaint.)

Most respondents said they’d never play fast and loose with the facts to get a better price.

“No,” says Tom Logue. “Never have, never plan to. I don’t think you can justify unethical behavior by saying everyone is doing it. Normally if the rates are too high I will just pick another place.”

Lying can have a ripple effect through the supply chain. Travel agent and frequent Consumer Traveler contributor Janice Hough remembers one client who asked for a negotiated, non-commissionable hotel rate in Dallas.

“Got a big discount,” she says. “And did me out of commisson on all his future Texas trips.”

Some guests eventually come clean about their transgressions. Anne Stratton recalls asking for a hotel rate for state employees and getting a $25-a-night price — a steal. And while she was a state employee, it wasn’t of the state she was visiting.

She admitted her omission when she checked in. “They really were pleasant about it,” she says. She was also allowed to keep the room.

What could be worse than that? Being caught.

“I worry about the embarrassment,” says Rick Cricow. “That’s silly, I know, but it’s just me. Plus, if caught, I worry that I would then have to pay the rack rate, or try to go elsewhere. It just doesn’t seem worth the hassle.”

There’s one final justification that hotel guests use when they lie about their their status: Hotels lie, too.

The lies can range from quoting a low base rate but then adding a mandatory “resort fee” to lying about their location (“walking distance to the beach” or “ski in/ski out”) or amenities.

And if a hotel can lie to us, then why can’t we lie back?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: