Are “custom” airfares good – or evil?

Photo of author

By Christopher Elliott

One way or another, the way you buy an airline ticket is about to change.

Behind the scenes, the propellerheads who create your fares are working on a smarter way to sell tickets. The airline industry is developing technology standards that could serve up a special fare intended only for you, based on how often you fly, where you live, your gender, age or marital status. But online travel agencies and consumer advocates are skeptical of customization.

Well, this is one time the airline industry almost got it right.

Custom fares are a terrific idea, as long as airlines create them with the passenger in mind.

Passenger privacy and fairness concerns

But the industry’s proposal, called Resolution 787, needs a little work before regulators with the Department of Transportation clear it for takeoff. There’s a right way to customize a fare, which puts air travelers in control, allows them to easily compare fares and doesn’t require they surrender any personal information. And, there’s an evil way.

“If by ‘customized’ you mean the airline will use its collected marketing knowledge of me to offer a special price just for me, then it is not going to be what I want,” says Jim Elekonich, a senior applications engineer from Toledo, Ohio. “It’s what they want me to want. How can it be anything else?”

Elekonich is afraid that if the airline offers custom prices, they will be a rip-off, “but with no way to prove it, since everyone else’s customized pricing will be known only to them,” he says. (Here’s what you need to know about your airline credit.)

The International Air Transport Association, the airline trade organization behind Resolution 787, claims custom fares would allow you to compare prices to ensure you’re getting the best deal, and it’s been making the rounds in Washington with a multimedia presentation to convince critics of its good intentions. But the association says the ability to generate a custom fare is just a technical standard and cannot guarantee that airlines will use it to make airfare shopping easier or more straightforward.

Bottom line: Passengers don’t trust airlines.

Insubuy is the premier online marketplace for travel insurance, visitors insurance, international travel medical insurance, international student health insurance, and exchange visitors insurance for individuals, groups, multinational companies, international workers, and others. Visit insubuy.com to get instant quotes, make side-by-side comparisons, and make an instant purchase of most insurance plans.

Concerns mount over airlines’ customer fare proposal impact

“Just the fact that airlines want to do this should be a big clue that it isn’t in consumers’ best interests,” says Rachel Thuerk. She is a risk manager from Cambridge, Mass. She’s afraid airlines will use their technology to calculate the maximum price you’re willing to pay for a ticket. It will then make that offer directly to you, and no one else. This means you could end up paying more than you otherwise would under the current system.

It’s something she says the aviation industry already does too well.

“Airlines excel at this kind of price-setting better than most other industries. They they can charge different prices based on days and times of travel and length of time before flights are booked,” she says. Customization would allow them to do that on an individualized level, she adds.

Of course, there’s a correct way to customize a fare. Already, passengers feel betrayed by “unbundling.” It is the act of quietly stripping the ability to check a bag or make a confirmed seat reservation from a base fare, in order to earn more money. Last year alone, the airline industry pocketed $27 billion in these “a la carte” fees.

With customization, the airline industry could have the opportunity to rebundle its fares on its own terms. That would be the wrong way to do it.

Customization only works when the consumer has some control of the process. If you can click on your favorite online travel agency, type in a destination, and inform the airline about your preferences, such as onboard wireless Internet, a meal, and a checked bag, then view the best offers from several airlines and compare them side-by-side, that would be customization done right. (IATA insists its system would do something “similar.”)

Airline custom fare proposals

Travelers are also worried about how much personal information they’d have to give up to receive a customized fare. As it stands, airlines seem to want as much information as they can collect before quoting a price under the proposed new standards. This includes your frequent-flier number, full name, date of birth and marital status.

Travelers say that some of that data is collected at the end of the booking process for security-screening purposes. None of it should be necessary to provide a fare quote.

“I don’t have a problem if airlines want to use technology to help their customers find service more amenable to their liking,” says Frank Hawkin. He is an online consultant in Washington. “Where I have a problem is creating the lack of transparency in pricing. Travel agencies and individuals can’t see all the fares and pricing offered.”

Innovation of gimmick?

Will the airline industry do the right thing, using the technology to allow us to find and compare the best fares? Jim Davidson is the president of Farelogix, a travel technology company. He asserts that competition will compel airlines to remain honest. As long as passengers don’t feel like they’re being profiled, the flying public will accept customization. (Related: It’s time to get real about “real time” airfares.)

What’s more, the new technology standards, if approved, would allow your airline to offer you things you didn’t even know you wanted. For example, what if you’re flying with your family, and you all want to sit together, and you need a power outlet to recharge your iPad on the journey? Customization would let your airline present you with a special package that guarantees those amenities.

“The technology can be used for good or for evil,” he says. “I believe airlines will use it for good.”

I hope he’s right. But we can rest assured that putting us, the consumers, in charge of choosing what we want, rather than having the airlines tell us what we want, is the best way to fly.

Are "custom" airfares good or evil?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Photo of author

Christopher Elliott

Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that empowers consumers to solve their problems and helps those who can't. He's the author of numerous books on consumer advocacy and writes three nationally syndicated columns. He also publishes the Elliott Report, a news site for consumers, and Elliott Confidential, a critically acclaimed newsletter about customer service. If you have a consumer problem you can't solve, contact him directly through his advocacy website. You can also follow him on X, Facebook, and LinkedIn, or sign up for his daily newsletter.

Related Posts