Stuck with a pair of shoes – and confused about Sears’ refund policy

ValeStock /
ValeStock /
Olga O’Hara wants to return the shoes she bought at, but she’s getting mixed signals from the company about how to do so. Is she stuck with her purchase?

Question: I recently ordered a pair of shoes online through The packing slip says I can return the items to any Sears store.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Trawick International. Trawick International offers a variety of international travel insurance, trip cancellation/interruption, adventure travel and student insurance plans. We offer 24/7 travel assistance to travelers domestically and internationally. We continue to research ground-breaking products and ideas which meet the needs of travelers everywhere. No matter what type of Travel Insurance product you need, we have the perfect travel insurance policy for you! Visit Trawick International to learn more.

I went to my nearest store and was told they can’t refund my money back to my credit card since I paid with PayPal. The only option they had was to issue a gift card. However, I don’t shop at Sears and I did not want a gift card.

They told me I could ship the items back. Well, I’d have to pay to ship those back, and I don’t want to do that.

Is there any way for me to return the items to the store and get my money refunded to my credit card? — Olga O’Hara, Salt Lake City

Answer: Sears should have allowed you to return the item to one of its stores. Like other merchants, Sears has a policy of refunding your purchase to the original method of payment. So if you paid cash, you’ll get a cash refund. If you paid by credit card, it goes back to your credit card.

Sears’ rules are explained on its site. But it doesn’t really mention the method-of-payment policy, at least not prominently.

By the way, many businesses have similar rules, and for good reason. Paying by gift card and asking for a cash refund sounds like the kind of scheme you’d read about on one of those consumer-hacker sites, where, among other things, they also explain how to take advantage of pricing mistakes and churn your credit cards. Enough said.

You have to dig deep into the Sears website to find this information. It’s under the refunds section, about halfway down the page: “Where appropriate, refunds will be issued in the same form as the original method of payment.”

Appropriate? That sounds like it’s subject to interpretation, don’t you think?

Here’s what puzzles me: is crystal-clear about your return options. “If you make an order that you wish to cancel, you may mail the order back after you have received it or return the merchandise to your local Sears store,” it says.

And yet, as I review the chat correspondence between you and a Sears representative, it seems as if, on at least one occasion, a Sears rep didn’t understand the store’s own policy, instructing you to ship the shoes back. Also, the employees seemed more eager to sell you something than to solve your problem. Tsk, tsk.

I think Sears could have been clearer about its return policies, especially as it pertains to the issuance of the refund. It might also train its employees to let them know that it’s absolutely fine to accept returns from

You also could have appealed this to someone higher up at Sears. Here are a few executive contacts. Email addresses at Sears follow the format [email protected]

I contacted Sears on your behalf. A representative called and arranged to let you take your shoes back to your store and will refund your PayPal account.

[poll id=”455″]