How much is your stolen property worth? Who can say?

Theft happens. Even at a hotel with a sterling reputation, like Marriott.

But here’s the question Melvin Windham is faced with: When your property is taken from a room, who gets to determine its value? Do you? Does the hotel? Or does some third party, like an insurance company?

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Cavalry Elite Travel Insurance --Cavalry Travel Insurance takes the worry out of travel by providing 24/7 access to medical and security professionals combined with the best medical evacuation and security extraction services. Cavalry gets you home safely when you need it most. Learn more at

Here are the specifics of his case: Windham stayed at the Marriott Downtown Richardson in the Dallas suburbs recently.

The door to his room wouldn’t close, so Marriott sent a technician to fix it. He picks up the story from there:

When I returned back to my room after breakfast, my room door was again unlocked and when I took inventory of my personal things, I notice that the bag containing my CDs were missing.

I reported this matter to the front desk and no one ever called to check to see what happen until I got ready to check out when I bought up the matter again.

The front desk person went to get a manager and took approximately 20 minutes to locate a manager. Two managers from Marriott approached me and asked what happened. They had never been notified about the missing items.

Windham was apparently told he could file a formal report after he returned, but when he tried, Marriott went into radio silence. His calls weren’t returned, either.

That’s when he contacted me.

Behavior like that is very un-Marriott-like, so after I gathered all the facts, I contacted the hotel. It responded to Windham with its verdict.

Marriott offered him a flat $75 settlement for his missing CDs.

(By the way, my reading of Texas lodging statutes suggests that he’s only entitled to $50, so this is a generous offer, where the law is concerned.)

This is a letter E to represent Elliott Advocacy (, a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization.
Keep an eye on what we are doing at Elliott Advocacy

Be the first to get the latest updates and exclusive content straight to your email inbox. 

We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address

He’s unhappy with that offer, since it doesn’t even begin to cover the cost of his collection.

Ah, I know what you’re thinking – why not just go to iTunes and download the music there? Forget CDs!

Tell that to my uncle who has an extensive vinyl collection. It is what it is. Also, it’s kind of beside the point.

The bigger question raised by this is: Who gets to determine the value of a stolen item?

I get that question often, and people rarely agree on the answer. A CD collection could have a high sentimental value, but an insurance company or hotel might take a different view.

And then, of course, there’s the law, which might say none of that matters, and that the hotel owes a customer nothing. That certainly applies to this case.

One solution is to keep receipts or get the items you’re traveling with assessed by a professional. That seems like a lot of trouble, but if you’re going to take something like a cherished CD collection or stamp collection on the road with you, knowing exactly how much it would cost to replace it might make some sense.

The other thing you might consider: Know what your rights are under the state’s lodging statues, just in case something is taken from your room. You never know.

At any rate, Marriott has made its final offer, and given that Windham can’t conclusively prove the CDs are worth more than $75, this might not be the worst offer.