Why did the Hotel Pennsylvania call me a no-show?

Why did Hotel Pennsylvania call him a no show and refuse to give him a room?

When Liam Goodman tries to check in to the Hotel Pennsylvania in New York City, the clerks tell him that no rooms are available. So he goes to another property. Can Priceline keep his money?


I’m a professional photographer and I was working in New York City recently. I had a double shift and was scheduled to work again in New York the next morning. Because I live a bit outside the city, I decided to book a hotel for the night. I did so through Priceline at a cost of $170. I went to check in at the Hotel Pennsylvania after I finished my second shift, at around 1:30 a.m.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by Global Rescue -- Global Rescue is the world’s leading provider of medical, security, evacuation and travel risk management services. Founded in 2004, Global Rescue has exclusive relationships with the Johns Hopkins Emergency Medicine Division of Special Operations and Elite Medical Group. Global Rescue provides best-in-class services that identify, monitor and respond to client medical and security crises. Learn more about Global Rescue.

When I arrived at the hotel I found a line of people waiting to check in, despite the late hour. As we waited, a hotel person came from behind the desk and informed us that there were no rooms available. They were still being cleaned and would not be ready for another three hours. He said if we had booked a room through an agency like Priceline, then we should call them and have them find us another room.

I called Priceline twice and talked to their robotic voice thing, but was not able to get through to a real person, despite their website saying customer service is available 24/7. I tried using the message chat function through their website but again was not able to message with a real person.

It was almost 2 a.m. at this point and I needed to get some sleep before going to work at 9:30 a.m. the next day. I was able to book a room through Hotel Tonight but it cost me $365.

Here’s my problem: Priceline won’t refund the $170 I prepaid for the Hotel Pennsylvania because they say I never checked in. The hotel reported me as a “no show.” I talked to three different customer service people – they all said the same thing. I’ve also emailed their “Executive Services” email and received the same response. Can you help me get a refund from Priceline? — Liam Goodman, Beacon, NY


The Hotel Pennsylvania should have found a room for you. In the hotel industry, there’s an industry standard rule that says if a hotel can’t accommodate you, it will “walk” you to a comparable property and cover your first night. If you’d asked a representative to “walk” you to another hotel, you might have been able to avoid paying an extra $365.

Priceline’s refusal to refund the money sounds absurd, but it makes sense. The online travel agency doesn’t know any more than what’s in your record. And your record says you didn’t check-in (which is true, but not the entire truth).

You need proof that Hotel Pennsylvania turned you away

Your experience is an important lesson for the rest of us. If you’ve pre-paid for a room through Priceline or Hotwire, and the hotel can’t accommodate you, make sure you get a confirmation of your cancellation in writing. In other words, you should have asked for proof on the Hotel Pennsylvania’s letterhead that the it turned you away. Unfortunately, you didn’t and the Hotel Pennsylvania listed you as a “no show” — and you almost lost your money.

I’m unhappy that the Executive Services email offered the same canned response as everyone else. We list the names, numbers and email addresses of Priceline’s customer service executives in company contacts database that can be accessed from our homepage.

The company should have researched your claim, which would have proven you were correct.

I contacted Priceline on your behalf. It refunded the $170 you spent for the room you never got at the Hotel Pennsylvania.