An American Airlines agent books two extra paid tickets — same passengers, same flight, same day — on a Million Miler’s credit card. The airline says it sent the refund months ago. The credit card company says it never arrived. Can he get his $5,162 back?
Question
My wife and I have been American Airlines customers for 35 years. I’m a Million Miler and AAdvantage Platinum Pro member.
Last year, I called to book mileage tickets for my granddaughter, her husband and their baby to visit us in El Salvador. While we were on the phone, the agent accidentally booked the same two tickets twice — once with miles, and once charging our Citi AAdvantage card $2,360 per ticket, plus $73 for seats and taxes. Same passengers, same flight, same confirmation code.
When my wife spotted the charge, I called American Airlines. The agent acknowledged the error and said the charges would be removed. They weren’t. I disputed the charges with Citibank, but American Airlines said it couldn’t refund while a dispute was open. On the advice of someone who claimed to have a contact inside American Airlines, I withdrew the dispute. That was a mistake.
American Airlines later showed the refund as processed back to our card. But the credit never appeared on our statement. I’ve called both companies repeatedly. Citibank eventually asked me not to call again. Six months later, American Airlines told me its review was final and it would take no further action.
I’m 75, and a Vietnam veteran on disability. We can’t afford to lose $5,162 over an agent’s error we didn’t cause. Can you help? — Donald Triplett, Nixa, Mo.
Answer
American Airlines should have fixed this the moment you called. When an agent makes a booking error of this magnitude, the airline has a clear obligation to reverse the charge. Full stop.
Under the Fair Credit Billing Act, you have the right to dispute charges for billing errors or goods or services you didn’t authorize. You had a strong case, but you made one critical mistake: You withdrew your credit card dispute before you had your money. Withdrawing a dispute is risky, and many banks won’t reopen one. Citibank closed its investigation, leaving you without protection.
You kept excellent records, but you needed a little more. The moment an airline agent admits an error, I recommend following up in writing. Ask for a case number. And don’t drop a credit card dispute unless the refund is actually in your account — not just promised and not just showing as “processed” on the airline’s internal system.
I list contact information for American Airlines executives on my consumer advocacy site, Elliott.org. Reaching out to one of them might have been helpful, as a last-ditch effort.
What to do when an airline refund says “processed” but never arrives
A refund that shows as “processed” isn’t a refund. It’s a promise. Until the credit posts to your account, treat the charge as unpaid. Here’s what I recommend:
- Get the refund details in writing. Ask the airline for the refund reference number, the date it issued the refund and the last four digits of the card it went to. American Airlines says it processes credit card refunds within seven business days, although the credit can take one or two billing cycles to show up on your statement.
- Take that information to your card issuer. Ask whether a credit is pending. If the bank can’t find it, the airline’s paperwork becomes your evidence.
- Dispute the charge in writing, and keep the dispute open. Under the Fair Credit Billing Act, a duplicate charge is a billing error. You have 60 days from the date of the statement on which the charge first appeared to dispute it. Don’t withdraw it until the money is back in your account, no matter who asks you to.
- File a complaint with the Department of Transportation. The DOT accepts complaints about airline refunds, and it forwards them to the airline. That puts your case on the record.
You’re not the first reader to run into this. Years ago, another passenger was billed by American Airlines, and then billed again. More recently, a reader was charged twice for airline tickets to Budapest. And even under the government’s new refund rules, airline refunds aren’t always automatic.
The lesson is the same every time: Keep your dispute alive until the money is in your pocket.
How this case ended
My advocacy team and I contacted American Airlines several times on your behalf. An airline representative promised they were looking into the case and would reach out to you directly with a resolution. Ultimately, you appealed your credit card dispute, and your bank sided with you.
I’m glad you received a full refund. Your case underscores the importance of keeping a credit card dispute alive until there’s a final resolution. If you don’t, even my team and I may not be able to help you.
Resolve it yourself
Stuck with a complaint? Build your path to a fix.
Answer two quick questions and get a step-by-step plan tailored to your situation.
Your plan
Have a question about this story? Tell us what happened — we read every comment.
Join the conversation