Can a rental company charge more for returning a car early?

Sometimes, because a shorter rental can void the discounted rate tied to the original length, which is disclosed in most rental terms as rates being subject to change if the rental period is altered. But a rate change applied by mistake is refundable, and in this case Avis admitted the early-return charge was applied in error.

Is an additional driver fee refundable if you return the car early?

Generally no. An additional driver fee that you initialed on the rental agreement at the counter is treated as a contractually agreed charge, not an error, and returning the car early does not reverse it. It is a separate line from any mistaken rate change and is handled differently in a dispute.

Who do you dispute a rental charge with when you booked through Booking.com?

It depends on who applied the charge. A booking-side problem goes to the travel agency, but a fee added at the rental desk, such as an early-return rate change, is the rental company's to reverse. Booking through a third party does not move the rental company's counter charges onto the agency.

What should you check on a rental receipt before leaving the lot?

Compare the total to your original quote, and confirm the rate, the number of days, fuel, insurance products and any driver or equipment fees. Question anything unexpected while the agent is in front of you. Once you have driven off, the same charge becomes a remote dispute with far less leverage.

Does a company admitting an error mean you get an automatic refund?

It should, but admission and payment are not the same step, and partial refunds are common. Get the admission in writing, confirm the exact amount conceded, and if the balance stalls, use the written admission to support a credit card dispute for that specific amount.

Avis early return fee charged in error. Getting it back

Christine Grosart’s car rental through Booking.com turned into a financial headache when Avis charged her extra by mistake. The company admitted its mistake, but sent her only a partial refund. Is the money gone forever?

Question

I booked a car in Spain through Booking.com for a rental with Avis. Everything seemed fine until I had a family emergency and had to return the vehicle early. At no stage during the booking process or at the rental desk was I informed that returning the car early would result in an increased cost.

Imagine my shock when I saw an unauthorized charge of $673 on my credit card. Returning the car early effectively doubled my rental cost. I never received any communication about this fee. It’s unjustified—Avis could have re-rented the car the second I dropped it off.

I’m a medic and I often work in the North Sea where mobile signals are difficult, so I’ve had to try and manage this via email and WhatsApp. It’s incredibly frustrating because Avis eventually admitted it was at fault and issued a refund, yet it’s still holding onto about $130.

I want the full amount owed, not a partial amount. Can you help me get my remaining money back? — Christine Grosart, Evercreech, England

Answer

Avis should have refunded you the moment it overcharged you. Actually, scratch that—it should have never charged you in the first place.

If a company admits it made a mistake, it shouldn’t be a struggle to get a full refund. It certainly shouldn’t require a medic to take time away from her duties in the North Sea to chase down a missing $130.

Rental car companies often have automated systems that trigger early return fees or rate changes if you drop the car off sooner than planned. While their policies often state that rates are subject to change if the rental period is altered, those changes shouldn’t be applied in error, as Avis later admitted happened in your case.

International Citizens Insurance helps expats, travelers and anyone far from home find the right insurance plan. Our knowledgeable agents will help you find the best plan at the right price and be your advocate for the life of your policy.

You could have avoided part of this by carefully reviewing the final receipt before leaving the rental lot. I know, you’re tired and want to get home, but that’s the moment you have the most leverage. You also did the right thing by starting a paper trail. As I always say, if it isn’t in writing, it didn’t happen.

When you run into a wall like this, you can always escalate your complaint to the executives at Avis or Booking.com. You can find those contacts on my site at Elliott.org.

I’ve dealt with similar fuzzy math from rental companies before. In a previous case involving Budget (which is owned by the same parent company, Avis Budget Group), a customer was hit with a cleaning fee that felt more like a penalty than a service charge. It seems these errors have a habit of leaning in the company’s favor.

I reached out to Avis on your behalf and asked it to review your case.

“We can confirm that the additional charge related to a quoted rate change due to early return was applied in error and should not have been charged,” a representative told me.

It turns out part of the missing money was an additional driver fee that you signed for at the time of rental. Avis sent over a copy of your signed agreement to prove it. “Charges that are clearly included and accepted on the signed rental agreement are considered contractually agreed upon and are not eligible for refund,” the company noted.

Your total refund comes to $552. While you didn’t get the driver fee back, you received the rest of your money back.

Should rental companies be required to disclose early-return fees before you drive off?

Yes

Christopher Elliott

Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that empowers consumers to solve their problems and helps those who can't. He's the author of numerous books on consumer advocacy and writes three nationally syndicated columns. He also publishes the Elliott Report, a news site for consumers, and Elliott Confidential, a critically acclaimed newsletter about customer service. If you have a consumer problem you can't solve, contact him directly through his advocacy website. You can also follow him on X, Facebook, and LinkedIn, or sign up for his daily newsletter.

Have a question about this story? Tell us what happened — we read every comment.

Join the conversation