This consumer would like Best Buy to send her a new refrigerator. Will it?

Will Best Buy send me a new refrigerator?

Jane Weir’s LG refrigerator doesn’t work and she wants Best Buy to give her a new one. But is that a reasonable request two years after purchasing it?


Best Buy sold me a defective LG refrigerator with a Geek Squad protection plan two years ago. Instead of helping me, Best Buy referred me to LG. After dozens of phone calls, and after a refrigerator technician stood me up and then rescheduled, LG diagnosed the problem as a defective compressor.

I am currently without a working fridge. I’ve contacted Best Buy multiple times and complained to the BBB.

I’d like to exchange the refrigerator for one with a working compressor. I would prefer a different brand instead of having to hope the compressor doesn’t die again and put me through all this again and again for the next ten years. I don’t want to wait for another month to go through LG when I bought it from Best Buy. I want a fridge in my home now. I want reimbursement for the actual loss of food and costs of ice, and meals out while I wait for them to live up to their agreement. Could you help me? — Jane Weir, Middletown, Md.


Best Buy sold you a refrigerator that doesn’t work, along with an expensive warranty, and then punted to the manufacturer when you had a problem? Welcome to the wacky world of electronics retailing. Best Buy buries the terms and conditions of its extended “Geek Squad” warranty on its site. They’re worth reviewing before you buy your next appliance or say “yes” to the Geek Squad. (Note: I couldn’t find the terms of your purchase, but they are similar.)

Why read all the fine print before you end up with a refrigerator that doesn’t work? Because it fully describes the coverage you are — and aren’t — getting. The biggest takeaway: Many of your Geek Squad coverages begin when the manufacturer’s warranty ends. So if LG covered your refrigerator under its warranty, Best Buy had to go through LG for a repair first.

For you, the most important part of the warranty was the replacement credit. If your appliance stops working, Best Buy appears to limit you to a $750 credit for new refrigerator.

As is so often the case with warranty cases, there’s what’s written — and there’s the right thing to do. Best Buy seems to be following its warranty terms. But the right thing to do, in terms of customer service, is to find you a working refrigerator. Quickly.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by International Citizens Insurance. International Citizens Insurance helps expats, travelers and anyone far from home find the right insurance plan. Our knowledgeable agents will help you find the best plan at the right price and be your advocate for the life of your policy.

Best Buy agrees to send you a new refrigerator

You could have appealed this to someone higher up at the company. We list the names, numbers and email addresses of the Best Buy customer service executives in our directory at Elliott Advocacy.

But you had waited long enough so I contacted the company on your behalf. The happy news? Best Buy approved your request for a new refrigerator. Enjoy!


Keep an eye on what we are doing at Elliott Advocacy

Be the first to get the latest updates and exclusive content straight to your email inbox. 

We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address