Spirit Airlines stopped flying six months ago, but its ghost is haunting the holiday travel season in ways you wouldn’t expect.
Fares on Spirit’s former routes rose a median 25.3% between June 2025 and this year, according to aviation data firm Cirium. Prices climbed on more than 90% of the 1,126 city pairs Spirit had served.
That sounds damning until you look at the control group. Cirium also checked about 37,000 city pairs Spirit never flew, and fares there rose 18.3%. The difference of about seven percentage points is a rough measure of what Spirit’s absence cost travelers on its old routes.
But now there’s a twist: JetBlue, the airline that tried to buy Spirit, is struggling too. It lost $257 million in the third quarter, up from $143 million a year earlier, as its average fuel price per gallon jumped 57%.
JetBlue also carries about $8.5 billion in debt and finance lease obligations. In late October, a group of its lenders hired financial adviser PJT Partners and the law firm Akin Gump. Creditors typically bring in that kind of help when they worry a borrower might not repay on schedule. JetBlue insists it has no plans to file for bankruptcy.
Still, if losing one low-fare airline raised your fare, what happens if you lose another?
How much is Spirit’s demise costing you?
The Spirit Effect, the tendency of fares to fall for every airline on a route when Spirit flew it, turned out to be smaller than you might think. Engine, a business travel company, ran federal ticket data and concluded Spirit’s exit explains about one point of the 16% national rise in average fares this spring. By its count, airlines that stayed on Spirit’s routes held their own prices roughly flat. Average fares on those routes jumped because Spirit’s cheap seats vanished.
But did the effect spill over into other markets? The best clue comes from Detroit and Las Vegas, the two big metros that leaned on Spirit most. Even after Engine stripped out Spirit’s city pairs, fares there rose 21% and 19%. Chicago’s rose about 10%.
What the airlines say
Airlines say fuel, not lost competition, is driving your fare higher this holiday season. Jet fuel hit a record $4.90 a gallon at the end of last month.
As for the Spirit Effect, they’d probably dispute that, too. After all, discount carriers moved fast to fill the void after Spirit’s demise. Frontier launched eight former Spirit routes by early July, with fares from $39 one way. Breeze added four routes from Atlantic City. JetBlue’s management says it has enough cash to reach profitability, a view JPMorgan analyst Jamie Baker shared after the airline’s October earnings call.
Consumers are skeptical
Air travelers aren’t so sure. They see the higher prices and the extras they have to pay at the airport. JetBlue, incidentally, just raised its checked luggage fees for the second time this year, pushing prices to as high as $70 for a first checked bag during peak holiday travel if paid within 24 hours of departure. This latest increase sets a new record as the highest checked bag fee among major U.S. airlines. (I’ll have more on this in tomorrow’s commentary.)
If you answered yes:
- How much more are you paying this year compared to last year?
- Which airline is more to blame for higher fares — JetBlue or the former Spirit?
If you answered no:
- Are you blaming higher fuel prices? Or something else (like airline opportunism)?
- What would it take to blame Spirit or JetBlue?
My take
I’m skeptical of anyone who offers a simple explanation for higher airfares. Airlines want you to blame fuel. It’s tempting to pin everything on Spirit’s demise instead.
The truth is a combination of the two, plus a tight supply of seats. Then there are the fees, like JetBlue’s new $70 checked bag charge. Sorting out how much each one contributes is difficult and complicated. What you’ll pay isn’t. No one doubts we’ll all spend more to fly home for the holidays this year.
Your turn
Have you paid more since Spirit stopped flying, or did another discount airline fill the void on your route? If you fly JetBlue out of Boston or New York, what alternative would you fly? Tell me in the comments.
Have a question about this story? Tell us what happened — we read every comment.
Join the conversation