Stillwater Insurance Company is a national insurance provider.
How to reach a person at Stillwater Insurance
Main: (855) 712-4092
Customer Service: (800) 220-1351
Toll Free : (800) 220-1351
Stillwater Insurance Responsiveness rating
The Elliott Responsiveness Rating scores companies based on how responsive they are to customers. Here's more information about our ratings.
What you need to know about Stillwater Insurance
The company responds to most customer complaints in a satisfactory manner.
How to resolve a problem with Stillwater Insurance
This guide on how to solve a customer service problem will help you resolve most problems with the company. You can also refer to the executive contacts below or contact our advocacy team directly.
Note: If you’re having customer service trouble, please use our proven methods for fixing any consumer problem before contacting a manager.
Stillwater Insurance mailing address
12500 I St
Suite 100
Omaha, NE 68137
Stillwater Insurance executive customer service contacts
Primary Contact
Cindy McDonald
AVP Customer Service
12500 I St
Suite 100
Omaha, NE 68137
cindy.mcdonald@stillwater.com
Secondary Contact
Julia Edmonston
Chief Financial Officer
12500 I St
Suite 100
Omaha, NE 68137
julia.edmonston@stillwater.com
Chief Executive
David Selman
12500 I St
Suite 100
Omaha, NE 68137
mark.davey@stillwater.com
What is the mailing address for Stillwater Insurance?
P.O. Box 45126, Jacksonville, FL 32232-5126.
How can I contact Stillwater Insurance customer service?
Email ins@stillwater.com or call (800) 220-1351.
What are Stillwater Insurance operating hours?
Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 9 p.m.; Saturday, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Eastern time.
How to get professional help with your Stillwater Insurance problem
If you need help with Stillwater Insurance, you can contact our advocacy team or just click the "Get Help" button. For immediate assistance, you can also send us a message on our Facebook group. Note: We do not charge for our advocacy.
Get Help