Stillwater Insurance
Stillwater Insurance Company is a national insurance provider.
What you need to know about Stillwater Insurance
The company responds to most customer complaints in a satisfactory manner.
How to resolve a problem with Stillwater Insurance
Try self-service first
Use our proven resolution methods.
Contact an executive
Start with the primary contact below, then escalate step by step if needed.
Get free advocacy help
Contact Elliott Advocacy for free mediation of unresolved complaints.
Note: If you’re having customer service trouble, please use our proven methods for fixing any consumer problem before contacting a manager.
We care about accuracy. If any of the following email addresses bounce back or the phone numbers are incorrect, please report it to us immediately through this form.
Verified contacts
Stillwater Insurance customer service executives
Maintained by Elliott Advocacy and updated regularly. Here’s how we do it →
Primary
Cindy McDonald
AVP Customer Service
Secondary
Julia Edmonston
Chief Financial Officer
Chief Executive
David Selman
Frequently asked questions about Stillwater Insurance
P.O. Box 45126, Jacksonville, FL 32232-5126.
Email ins@stillwater.com or call (800) 220-1351.
Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 9 p.m.; Saturday, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Eastern time.
Outdated info? Report it here
Disclaimer: Contact information is believed reliable but not guaranteed. Executives change contact details frequently. If an email bounces or a number is wrong, report it immediately. Published July 31, 2019. Updated April 22, 2024.