What's the book corporate America doesn't want you to read? Find out now -- or you could get scammed.

A lost laptop on El Al

December 10, 2005

Q: I recently had my laptop computer confiscated by security agents before my El Al flight from Tel Aviv to Paris. I need your help recovering it.

I’m not sure why the computer was taken from me. On the flight over, I was questioned for over an hour. Agents sifted through all my belongings, every square inch of them. I was asked to pull down my pants and take off my underwear. I was told that I would not be allowed to take my laptop, my hair straightener, my hair dryer and my body exfoliant on board the plane.

The most memorable question was, “Why do you smile so much?”

On the return flight, my laptop was again taken away from me. I was told by one of the security agents that no one is allowed to take laptops on El Al. My master’s thesis was on the computer, and it needed to be turned in the next day. I had some major changes to make to it.

To my disgust, a few people flipped open laptops after our plane took off. When we landed, my laptop was nowhere to be found. I spent two hours at the baggage claim, and left with nothing except a case number.

Please help me. El Al is holding my master’s thesis hostage.

– Mita Patel, Elyria, Ohio

A: Your story brings back memories of my master’s thesis, which was also held up (I think there’s an unwritten rule in academia that every thesis or dissertation must be delayed for some reason or another). I couldn’t blame an airline for it, though.

What happened to you isn’t that unusual. El Al’s security is legendary. It subjects passengers to all kinds of questions, prodding and searches in the name of security. I love that question about smiling, though. I had no idea that a happy face was an indication of criminal intent. Guess you learn something new every day.

Although the invasive once-over you had to endure at the hands of El Al’s security was probably unavoidable, the problem you encountered with your laptop was completely preventable. Your mistake was traveling with your only working copy of your thesis. You could have – and should have – bought an inexpensive flash-memory keychain, and backed up your important documents.

Oddly, I heard from another El Al passenger who had a laptop confiscated the same week you did. I took both cases to El Al and asked what was happening. Are laptop computers now banned from El Al flights?

“They are not,” airline spokeswoman Sheryl Stein told me. “Sometimes, when security sees something suspicious, they will take the laptop and then return it after the flight. But laptop computers are permitted.”

Shortly after I brought both queries to El Al’s attention, the laptop computers were returned to their owners. I am confident that you would have received your laptop eventually, but it is certainly nice to have it back sooner rather than later. I think El Al needs to make an effort to keep the separation between passengers and their PCs as brief as possible.


Q: I recently had my laptop computer confiscated by security agents before my El Al flight from Tel Aviv to Paris. I need your help recovering it.

I’m not sure why the computer was taken from me. On the flight over, I was questioned for over an hour. Agents sifted through all my belongings, every square inch of them. I was asked to pull down my pants and take off my underwear. I was told that I would not be allowed to take my laptop, my hair straightener, my hair dryer and my body exfoliant on board the plane.

The most memorable question was, “Why do you smile so much?”

On the return flight, my laptop was again taken away from me. I was told by one of the security agents that no one is allowed to take laptops on El Al. My master’s thesis was on the computer, and it needed to be turned in the next day. I had some major changes to make to it.

To my disgust, a few people flipped open laptops after our plane took off. When we landed, my laptop was nowhere to be found. I spent two hours at the baggage claim, and left with nothing except a case number.

Please help me. El Al is holding my master’s thesis hostage.

– Mita Patel, Elyria, Ohio

A: Your story brings back memories of my master’s thesis, which was also held up (I think there’s an unwritten rule in academia that every thesis or dissertation must be delayed for some reason or another). I couldn’t blame an airline for it, though.

What happened to you isn’t that unusual. El Al’s security is legendary. It subjects passengers to all kinds of questions, prodding and searches in the name of security. I love that question about smiling, though. I had no idea that a happy face was an indication of criminal intent. Guess you learn something new every day.

Although the invasive once-over you had to endure at the hands of El Al’s security was probably unavoidable, the problem you encountered with your laptop was completely preventable. Your mistake was traveling with your only working copy of your thesis. You could have – and should have – bought an inexpensive flash-memory keychain, and backed up your important documents.

Oddly, I heard from another El Al passenger who had a laptop confiscated the same week you did. I took both cases to El Al and asked what was happening. Are laptop computers now banned from El Al flights?

“They are not,” airline spokeswoman Sheryl Stein told me. “Sometimes, when security sees something suspicious, they will take the laptop and then return it after the flight. But laptop computers are permitted.”

Shortly after I brought both queries to El Al’s attention, the laptop computers were returned to their owners. I am confident that you would have received your laptop eventually, but it is certainly nice to have it back sooner rather than later. I think El Al needs to make an effort to keep the separation between passengers and their PCs as brief as possible.

Christopher Elliott is the author of Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals. Critics have called it “eye-opening” and “inspiring” — it’ll “grab your attention and won’t let go.” Order your copy now on Amazon, Barnes & Noble or iTunes.

1 comment

  • Andrew Carney

    I am an American temporarly in Ukraine to help my wife care take her mother.

    I need help in recovering a small container with personal papers, bank cards, health insurance cards and a myraid of contact names and addresses. It was about 5 inches long, 3 inches wide and 3 inches thick. The flight was from Borispol Airport, Ukraine to Bengurian Airport in Isreal. The flight was at 9:25pm on April 15, 2008. I left the container at my seat.

    I visited El Al in Kiev, Ukraine. They assured me that they would get back to me. They never did. I was given numbers that never answer, go dial tone after keying, or that no longer are connected with El Al. I was told to call Bengurian and they only speak Hebrew. There are deadlines to this process. The only thing they can do is scare you with thugs that ask you the reason you are in Ukraine.

    I need help all my life was condensed into this little container. Please reach me if there is an agency that El Al must answer to or there is any way to solve this matter. My e-mail is jakecarney36@yahoo.com. My telephone number in Ukraine is 011 380 44 413 4970. Please call back if a person answers who speaks only Russian.

    Thank you for your help.

    Sincerely,
    Andrew Carney

Previous post:

Next post: