United Airlines closes the gap with American Airlines in April

American Airlines vs United Airlines

The competition for the worst company in America tightened up in April as United Airlines pulled within nine cases of archrival American Airlines.

America’s largest airline clung to the number-one position with 29 cases, or nearly 6 percent of the complaints. United Airlines came in second with 20 cases, or 4 percent. Expedia ranked third.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by World Nomads
-- World Nomads travel insurance has been designed by travelers for travelers, to cover your trip essentials. Even if you run out of travel insurance or leave without it, World Nomads can cover you. We don't just keep you and your family protected, with us, you'll travel smarter and safer. Get more information at World Nomads.

I’ll have more on the cases and what they mean in a moment. But first, let’s review last month’s other numbers.

A record-breaking April

I report monthly traffic and other metrics because you are stakeholders in this advocacy site. Readers represent the single-largest donor to this nonprofit organization. My team and I could not publish it without your help.

April was yet another record-breaking month:

✓ Pageviews rose 6 percent to 773,719 for the month, compared with the previous year, a new record. User sessions jumped 7 percent to 405,380. Our bounce rate declined by one percent to 72 percent.

✓ Active newsletter subscribers jumped by 544 to 21,977, also a new high water mark.

✓ We received 488 cases, up 59 percent from a year ago. That’s a new record, too.

Our journey to a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization is taking my team into an exciting new direction. Last month, we removed all of the display advertising from our site. Ads don’t belong on a nonprofit advocacy site.

This month, we’ll be holding our spring fundraiser in an effort to make up for the revenue. We’ve set big goals, but I’m confident that with your help, we can meet them. Here’s how to get an early start by making a contribution.

A closer look at our cases

Here’s how we did in April.

April 2018 Cases
Rank Top 25 Companies Total Complaints Percent
1 American Airlines 29 5.94%
2 United Airlines 20 4.10%
3 Expedia 11 2.25%
4 Delta Air Lines 10 2.05%
5 British Airways 9 1.84%
6 WOW Air 8 1.64%
7 American Express 7 1.43%
8 Priceline 7 1.43%
9 Sears Holdings 7 1.43%
10 TripMate 7 1.43%
11 Amazon.com 6 1.23%
12 Norwegian Cruise Line (NCL) 6 1.23%
13 Aeromexico 5 1.02%
14 Airbnb 5 1.02%
15 Hertz Rent a Car 5 1.02%
16 HomeAway (Expedia) 5 1.02%
17 Justfly.com 5 1.02%
18 Travelocity (Expedia) 5 1.02%
19 Turkish Airlines 5 1.02%
20 Air Canada 4 0.82%
21 Lufthansa 4 0.82%
22 Spirit Airlines 4 0.82%
23 AT&T 3 0.61%
24 Alaska Airlines 3 0.61%
25 Allianz 3 0.61%
Total Cases: 488
Total Cases April 2017: 308
Percent Difference Year Ago: 58.44%

We’ve received a lot more cases in 2018. But we’ve also grown from the previous month. Here’s March:

March 2018 Cases
Rank Top 25 Companies Total Complaints Percent
1 American Airlines 31 6.87%
2 United Airlines 20 4.43%
3 Delta Air Lines 10 2.22%
4 Sears Holdings 10 2.22%
5 Amazon.com 8 1.77%
6 Enterprise Rent-A-Car 8 1.77%
7 TripMate 8 1.77%
8 AT&T 7 1.55%
9 American Express 7 1.55%
10 Expedia 7 1.55%
11 Airbnb 6 1.33%
12 Emirates 6 1.33%
13 Marriott 6 1.33%
14 Southwest Airlines 6 1.33%
15 Spirit Airlines 6 1.33%
16 Alaska Airlines 5 1.11%
17 Facebook 5 1.11%
18 Google 5 1.11%
19 Hotwire 5 1.11%
20 Norwegian Cruise Line (NCL) 5 1.11%
21 Air Canada 4 0.89%
22 British Airways 4 0.89%
23 Carnival 4 0.89%
24 Hertz Rent a Car 4 0.89%
25 Justfly.com 4 0.89%
Total Cases: 451
Total Cases March 2017: 337
Percent Difference Year Ago: 33.83%

Bear in mind, these represent only the most serious cases, usually deserving of our advocates’ attention. Many more cases don’t go through our help form.

We count our cases in order to track the best and worst companies. They represent a helpful snapshot of consumer sentiment from month to month.

What these numbers mean

Our case numbers are reflected in the latest gauge of consumer sentiment reported by the authoritative American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI). And, although some may argue with our methodology, it’s difficult to dispute that airlines have some of the worst customer service in the world.

What’s debatable? Which major airline is the biggest bottom-feeder. Our numbers say American; the ACSI says it’s United.

Two numbers you can’t argue with are our traffic and overall cases. Not to get political, but the current administration, which seems infatuated with corporate America and is hell-bent on deleting every consumer regulation on the books, has made a significant contribution to this site’s dramatic growth. It’s not quite enough to make me switch my party affiliation — I’m a registered independent voter — but I’m grateful nonetheless.

Thanks for your support during these difficult times for consumers. We’re going to have an even better May with your help.

LinkedIn
×