This $440 Amtrak voucher is worthless! Can you help me?

Traveling on an Amtrak voucher? Maybe he isn't.

Mitchell Bator cashes in an Amtrak voucher for his recent journey from Florida to Connecticut. As he settles into his seat, he is pleased that the entire trip is costing him just $14 in cash. Unfortunately, his credit card statement tells a different story.


I had an Amtrak voucher in the amount of $440. Last month, I went to their website and booked a trip from West Palm Beach to Stamford at a total price of $454. I used my credit card to pay the $14 difference between the cost and the Amtrak voucher — or so I thought.

Elliott Advocacy is underwritten by With nearly 20 years in the industry, over 128 airport covered in the U.S. and Canada, and over 1,000 Hotel and Parking Partners-we provide travelers the best options on how to get to the airport when flying. Whether you want to; drive yourself and park near an Airport (Airport Parking), stay the night before your flight at an airport hotel and leave your car (Hotel and Parking Package), or take a shared Shuttle/Private Car/Limo to the Airport- we got you covered. The best deals can be found online, and booking a reservation has never been easier. You can explore all of our options by visiting us at,,, and

Immediately after returning from my trip, I received my credit card statement in the mail. And in it was a charge for the total amount of the trip!

Amtrak told me that nothing could be done to correct the charge now that I completed my trip. When I asked to speak to a supervisor, I was told they only deal with administrative issues. When I inquired if they could research my booking electronically, the agent said she could see where I was trying to use the credit, but it was only “summarized.” I still had to hit the confirmation button again to apply the credit, which she claimed I apparently did not do.

I hope that you will be able to have the $440 travel credit that I wanted to use for the trip credited to my Visa credit card. Thank you in advance for any assistance you can provide. — Mitchell Bator, West Palm Beach, Fla.


Whew! That’s some sticker shock.

You expected to be spending less than $20 on this trip. So when you saw the $440 charge, it’s no wonder you thought had been caught in some bait-and-switch scheme.

At the time that you booked your vacation, you had carefully entered all the numbers on your Amtrak voucher. After the value was applied, the screen showed that the balance was $14. You added your credit card information, clicked confirm — and you were on your way.

An Amtrak voucher rejection

You never expected that post-transaction, the company’s computer system would reject your voucher in favor of your credit card — for the entire cost of the ticket. In the end, your Amtrak voucher was unilaterally discarded.

To add insult to injury, when you asked the company for help, the representatives blamed this mishap on “user error.”

In other words, you caused this problem. But no one ever clarified what you had done wrong.

Mistakes happen. That’s true. But the fact remained that Amtrak charged you $440 more than what its website had indicated. And then the company made no effort to correct the problem.

That is not consumer friendly. Not at all.

User error?

Finally, your paper trail shows that you reached a representative who told you she could see that during the transaction you had added your Amtrak voucher into the payment field. She wasn’t quite sure what happened after that but suggested that you had forgotten to click the confirm button.

Since you had completed this purchase and taken the trip, it seemed highly unlikely that you had neglected to click confirm. But I digress.

You thought it would be easy to persuade this employee to reverse the charges on your credit card for the amount of your Amtrak voucher. It wasn’t. The representative told you that your request was not possible since you had already completed your trip.

It’s frustrating when customer service representatives refuse to go off their standard script — even in the face of a logical solution. I hate it, and I know you do, too.

Getting nowhere with Amtrak, you turned to our advocacy team for help.

Our company contacts listed on our site can be a powerful tool for our readers to resolve a problem on their own. And we list a variety of Amtrak contacts there.

Amtrak voucher Success!

But you had already been put through the Amtrak wringer, so I reached out to the company on your behalf. I asked our executive contact for reconsideration of your situation.

And that’s when things took a positive turn.

The Amtrak executive with whom I spoke agreed that the company should refund the charge.

Your Amtrak voucher has now been applied to the original ticket, as it should have been in the first place. And I’m pleased to have helped.

It’s nice when justice prevails.

8 thoughts on “This $440 Amtrak voucher is worthless! Can you help me?

  1. Well done, Ellioteers! My only question since I’ve never used Amtrak, is do they not send a confirmation email like airlines do? That might have said the amount and “to card ending in 1234”? Still I’m glad they FINALLY did the right thing.

    1. Yes, Amtrak does send a confirmation. Unfortunately, Mr. Bator didn’t check that confirmation until after his trip.

    2. And he could and should have checked his credit card online to see if the $14 had been charged. He would have found out immediately the full amount had been charged (in the pending charges section).

  2. If this is truly confusing (I’ve not applied a voucher on Amtrak) – an added step would be for to *fix* the problem!

  3. After booking my first ever trip on Amtrak last month, I strongly suspect that the website does not interact directly with their reservation system. I think it just sends an e-mail to a person who then transcribes the information into their system. The reason I think that is because my address has a few typos and they are not the sort of typos that I would make. I called Amtrak after noticing it in my confirmation e-mail, but they said that they could not fix it and that it didn’t matter anyway because it is an electronic ticket.

    1. If so, that’s an awfully quick person – every time I’ve booked an Amtrak ticket online, I’ve gotten a confirmation email within seconds.

  4. My limited experience with Amtrak is that there are numerous errors with booking and trip execution, most of which are fairly trivial. However, once I tried to make a reservation for the next day, and found the site offline for the entire day. That was frustrating, and I ended up having to book a flight instead.

  5. As an avid Amtrak rider (Select Executive member), I can attest that the evoucher application is not as user friendly as it could be. You enter the voucher and it displays and shows an amount, but then there is an additional step to actually apply it to your reservation. Not saying the OP didn’t do something correctly, just that it isn’t a straight forward process.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: