What's the book corporate America doesn't want you to read? Find out now -- or you could get scammed.

Seven money-saving secrets

May 15, 2006

Travelers are notorious penny-pinchers. If you aren’t the kind of person who spends hours online just to save a few bucks on a hotel room, you’re probably related to someone who does.

That may be one reason why there are few in the business who talk glowingly about their best customers being educated customers. The industry credo is something more along the lines of, “ignorance is bliss.”

There are notable exceptions. Travel agents, for example, spend a lot of time educating their customers about everything from the right place to book a business meeting to the perfect vacation spot. But even they don’t always tell you everything. More on that in a second.

In fact, the travel industry is full of secrets. Knowing them can help you save a lot of money on your next trip. Here are seven of them:

1. You can still wait until the last minute for a deal.

Pick up any travel magazine or turn on your TV, and you’ll see a travel “expert” warning you to book now if you want to still get a good deal on an airline ticket or hotel room. They’ll use big words like “load factors” and “occupancy rates.” Very impressive. But take a closer look at those numbers. Even in the best of times, load factors — a measure of how full a plane is flying — are around 80%. Do the math: that means 20% of the plane is still empty. How about hotels? Analysts get excited when average occupancy rates hit 70%. In other words, close to one-third of the rooms are unoccupied. And what happens with empty seats and rooms? They go on sale, often at the last minute.

2. Your travel agent is taking a commission.

In the mid-1990s, airlines began eliminating travel agency bonuses, and in response, agencies added booking fees to make up the shortfall (the average charge is $27 per airline ticket). By starting to bill customers, agents left their customers with the impression that they were now working exclusively for them, in much the same way as a lawyer, accountant or any other professional does.

But that’s not entirely true. Airlines may no longer pay commissions, but other travel companies, such as hotels, car rental agencies and cruise lines, do pay them, and sometimes generously. So how does this information save you money? Knowing that your agent is being compensated by the other side would make any traveler check the “deal” they’re getting from an agent against the prices they’re being quoted online. If there’s a big discrepancy, maybe there’s a problem.


3. The Internet isn't always the cheapest place to buy travel.

Don't count travel agents out, despite what I just wrote about commissions. Often, a good agent will have access to special deals you can't find on the Internet — in which case the booking fee is well worth the price that you'll pay for your ticket. How can agents score a better price than the Internet? Agencies can have affiliate agreements with a large travel company that negotiates lower rates on their behalf. (Think volume discount.) That's one reason that you should never limit your bargain-hunting to the Internet: because all the deals aren't online. Some of them can even be found in (brace yourself, please) the newspaper. Often, tour operators will advertise ridiculously low fares and package deals in the Sunday travel section.

4. Two roundtrip airline tickets are sometimes cheaper than one.

Airlines use sophisticated computer algorithms to price their tickets — a process called "yield management." Basically, it tries to predict demand for tickets and sets the price accordingly. But it doesn't always work so well. That's why a one-way ticket can cost more than a round-trip ticket (the system thinks you're a big-spending business traveler, and charges more). The solution, as counter-intuitive as it may seem, is to buy two sets of advance-purchase roundtrip tickets, but to use only half of each — a process called "back-to-back" ticketing. The trick works best with a short trip where you aren't staying over a Saturday night (the system thinks you're a big-spending business traveler if you don't stay over a Saturday night, too). Airlines frown on passengers who use this clever strategy, but legal experts I've spoken with say it is perfectly legal.

5. Car rental insurance is usually unnecessary.

When you rent a car, you'll be cautioned about the need to buy an optional collision-damage waiver. You may even be shown a picture of a car that was damaged, and for which the unfortunate rental customer had to pay thousands of dollars because he didn't buy the insurance.

But don't be swayed. Check your car insurance policy. It usually will cover you. If not, then rent with a credit card. Visa, for example, will cover you for most car rentals (but read the fine print carefully). The optional insurance is almost entirely profit to the car rental company, and employees are offered hefty bonuses for engaging in hard-sell tactics. Often, such policies can double the cost of your rental.

6. Where you buy your hotel room matters.

Hotels often have two classification systems for their rooms: the published categories, like standard, suite, ocean view; and the unpublished categories. These are secret, internal ways of tagging a room, ranging from the least desirable (that would be the one between the elevator and the ice machine, over the kitchen and under the disco) to the most desirable (usually, the presidential suite).

A hotel will classify its rooms based on how much you paid for it and where you bought it from. Did you score a cheapo room on a discount travel site? Odds are, you'll end up in the worst room in the house.

Here's how to still save money and get a better room: buy directly from the hotel's Web site. It typically treats its direct-booking customers better than outsiders. Hotels will deny they do this when they're on the record. But off the record, they admit it happens.

7. Flying is cheaper than driving.

As incredibly counterintuitive as it might sound, it's often cheaper to fly than to drive — particularly on longer flights.

How's that? Consider that even when gas prices soar, airfares have remained extremely low by historical standards. The bad news is that airlines can't make any money, because they have to pay sky-high fuel bills. But the good news is it's less expensive to zip across the country on a plane than to fill up your gas-guzzling SUV numerous times, and spend hours and hours on the road. There's no telling how long this will last. Eventually, air fares will have to rise so that airlines can start to cover their expenses (on some routes, notably to Europe, they already have). But until then, leave the car home and head to the airport if you want to save some money.

So what are your favorite travel secrets? Send me an e-mail and I'll include them in a future article.

Christopher Elliott is the author of Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals. Critics have called it "eye-opening" and "inspiring" -- it'll "grab your attention and won't let go." Order your copy now on Amazon, Barnes & Noble or iTunes.

9 comments

  • Suzanne

    I might be getting commissions, but you should see what I go through to actually collect! Cruises pay very promptly, cars pay rarely if ever, many hotels pay with a bloody battle if at all, and airlines pay once in a blue moon if you are lucky enough to sell enough for an override. Yes; I make good money, but I work a bare minimum of 65 hours a week. I have so many customers I am turning away new business. Most people who pay $1000 per night for a hotel room don’t want to book it any other way than with an agent. They want to be able to sue someone if they don’t like the draperies. My clients feel the value I provide to them if so worth it that I actually save them hundreds of dollars per trip. The other day I found a way to book deluxe rooms at the Dorchester in London at 75 GBP per night less than the website AND the GDS. This is a treasure. The client would have never figured this out on her own, and quite honestly, she is too busy counting her millions to have the time/inclination to do the work that comes naturally to me. If you can latch on to a travel agent who CARES and knows what he/she is doing, you are very lucky and will save your precious money and time.

  • Evan

    Quite a few airlines will kick you out of their frequent flyer program and void your miles if you are caught with back to back ticketing. After all, you enter into a contract to fly two legs, not one when you purchase a round trip ticket. Airlines understand that sometimes you may not be able to take the second leg for a variety of reasons but holding back to back tickets isn’t one of them. I’m not saying I agree, simply what I observe happening.

  • Bill Armstrong

    The last time I was booked travel by a “corporate” travel agent, the nights in my hotel didn’t match up with the flight. I would have no place to sleep for the last night.
    As this is, unfortunately, entirely in line with my usual experience with corporate travel agents, I cancelled the hotel reservation and made my own directly, so that he would definitely not get a commission. I realize that travel agents can sometimes get a pretty good deal. However, the industry does a very poor job of culling the incompetents from their group. Travel agents have potentially cost me far more because of their oversights than they have ever saved me due to their deals. There’s only one time I didn’t catch a travel agent “goof up” in time, and by not taking any responsiblity for it whatsoever, they certainly proved their worth or lack thereof. The good travel agents are so busy that you hardly can get to see them.

  • Albert O’Connor

    Too often all the bad apples make all the money and never take responsibility. In all fairness I do not like to work with business travelers. For one they know more about what they do and what they want than they will share. I am not a soothsayer able to leap into the mind of Mr Travelalatime, you have to be able to lucidly tell me what is required and how you want it done. Barring that I need to ask questions. Most of the business travelers are not the type to answer questions. On the other hand Travel Agents should be used by sometime travelers and leisure travelers. I shudder when I hear Mrs Doctorswife or sometimes Mr Doctor tell me ” I spent all weekend on the computer planning our trip to Kamchataka for next week. By the way how long does it take to get visas and shots? I how the spas are as great as I heard they would be?” No I think that some people should always use travel agents and some should never use them. Whine over.

  • Diane

    Actually, I found each of the contributors had comments of interest, which I hope to remember. I’d found a young woman very efficient, and trustworthy as a travel agent, while she was employed by AAA. When she became an employee of a local travel agency, she tacked on every possible cost that she could, plus the agency booking fee. Having never done it before, I’d thought it best to go through an agent to book train travel, and some interesting sight reservations, in East Europe, through a professional. I was taking my son w/me, and was a bit surprised when she charged each of us a full fee for the one phone call she made for this service. Since that experience, I book my cruises, and other travel, online.

  • Suraj Zutshi, CTC, CTIE

    Wow. Just happened to run across the article and comments. After 33 years in the business, what has changed is the consumer. Most have unreaistic expectations and have no cpncept about the value of time.
    As one gentlemen says above, good travel agents are so busy they are turning business away. Like us. No we do not charge a fee for booking cruises or turs since we get paid by the suppliers. I am happy to see some consumers who also ask about our fees at the onset so there are no suprises. You get what you pay for and corporate travel agents are not travel agents at all, they are order takers and you are a corporate entity to them. DON’T lump all travel agents together. We earn every penny and we would not have celebrated 25 years last month if all we cared about was fees.

  • Jennifer

    Where on earth can you go today and receive a service for FREE? Time is money and if you walk into an agency for a SERVICE why would a person think it’s free? So book online (you’ll still pay some fees) spend your own time trying to figure out your own itinerary and hope you understand that if you booked a code share flight and the flight number says CO but next to it it also says VS, I’m sure you’ll wind up at the correct gate. Or if your flight shows “direct” and you wind up stopping along the way for over an hour and realized yes it’s direct but it’s a “through” flight and NOT a non stop, you’ll be fine with it. Assume your infant is free on an international flight and pay when you arrive at the airport. And by all means while in Paris and not sure what to order on the menu get Tete de veau , you’ll love it. It’s calfs head! It’ will be a nice treat after you picked up a car that you thought you booked as a four door, air conditioning, automatic but it’s a manual with no air, diesel that you just put regular gas in because you were convinced you booked one that required regular gas. The list goes on!

  • Jennifer

    “You get what you pay for and corporate travel agents are not travel agents at all, they are order takers and you are a corporate entity to them. DON’T lump all travel agents together. We earn every penny and we would not have celebrated 25 years last month if all we cared about was fees.” I’ve worked for the airlines, small agencies as a leisure agent(for years) and now I am a corporate agent and that is NOT true we are not order takers we are just a consultative and our corporate clients are not a corporate entitiy to us. We feel that we offer a personalized service and strive for excellence. As a matter of fact corporate agents are FAR more informed on travel industry policy and trends. The difference between us is our negotiated rates, how many clients we handle our volume and our technology. I exchange my own tickets, and handle my own invoicing, even on 70 clients or more, I advise on documentation, weather, travel warnings, hotel information, restaurants, possible tours, area location, currency. Everything is the same except the volume. No we don’t book cruises, consolidator tickets or air, hotel and car as a “package” we don’t need to each part is discounted for the corporate traveler through negotiated rates. So don’t lump us all together. We care about our clients, just like you our clients pay our salary!

  • http://www.conciergetvl.com Suzanne

    Regarding fees and travel agents, I only charge fees for airline tickets and FITs (which require extensive planning and a full, 10 -20 page itinerary telling the clients everything to see and do, where to eat, etc.). I also call Italy several times to book museums, dinner tables, etc. on their behalf. Half of the time I don’t get ANY commission from the hotels because they simply do not keep up their end of the deal. I have a case right now where the David Citadel hotel in Jerusalem owes me $700, and I will never see it. I have faxed and emailed them over thirty times, and they just ignore me (and the Israel Tourism Association as well). If the hotel were in the US, I would be able to collect, but over 95% of my business is foreign travel. For those who think I am a fat cat over an expensive trip they booked, it isn’t always true. In the cases where I do make a big commission, I buy such gifts as a $250 certificate to the clients’ favourite restaurant and present it when I take them for a nice lunch. To sell a client a cruise they won’t like simply because I will make a larger commission is sheer stupidity in terms of creating a life-long friend and client.

    Most of my clients are lovely, upscale people who prefer to tap my expertise rather than taking a big chance on the unknown. They want to deal with someone who CARES how the trip turns out and is there for them in good times and bad. Most people who book on their own also buy terrible travel insurance (or none!), and they have no clue how this might affect them in cases of accident, illness, or death.

    Suzanne Alexander, Marietta, GA.

Previous post:

Next post: