What's the book corporate America doesn't want you to read? Find out now -- or you could get scammed.

7 lessons learned from the summer of 2007

August 27, 2007

Congratulations, you’ve survived the summer of 2007 — the worst summer for travel in modern history. No, wait, make that since the invention of the wheel.

Or was it? Well, no.

Despite what you may have read, heard or seen on TV, the summer of 2007 was pretty average for travelers. That’s according to an online poll of more than 100 readers that I ran last week, and a bigger survey of travelers released at the end of August by insurance company Access America.

One in ten respondents to my poll described the summer as “better than average,” and 54 percent said it had been “average.” About two in ten readers though it was worse than average. And get this: five percent even called it the “best ever.”

No one should be shocked by these results. We journalists are fixated on anything that flies: big jets, executive jets and private planes. And for air travelers, it’s been a rough couple of months. But factor in cars — which is how most of us get around — trains and other mass transit, plus hotels, and you get … average.

Even though it was a so-so summer, it was also pretty memorable in other respects. Here are seven takeaways from the busy travel season:

Always apply for your passport early. On Jan. 23, the U.S. government began requiring citizens of the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Bermuda to present a passport to enter the United States when arriving by air from any part of the western hemisphere.

Suddenly, everyone wanted a passport. Result: a massive backlog of applications and months-long delays. At its worst, during late May and early June, dozens of despondent travelers were contacting me every day for help with their paperwork. Thousands of vacations were postponed or canceled, even after the State Department eased its rules.

Lesson learned: This might be a good time to get that passport for your 2008 vacation.

Air travel isn’t as bad as they say. It’s probably worse. You’ve seen the stories about how this is supposedly the worst summer for air travel since the Wright Brothers took to the skies. Don’t believe everything you read. In some respects, it’s one of the best summers. Fares are low and the industry’s safety record is excellent.

But when it comes to delays, cancellations and customer service, it’s been awful. The worst summer ever? No. If you take a hard look at the numbers, whether they’re released by the government or Flightstats.com, a far more troubling trend emerges. This is shaping up to be the worst year for commercial air travel. Ever.

Lesson learned: Next summer, drive.

The grass isn’t greener over there — especially if “over there” is Europe. Your mama was right when she told you the grass wasn’t greener over there. Or was it your kindergarten teacher who said that? Anyone who thought they could escape to Europe was sorely mistaken this summer. The dollar hit a 120-day high of 1.38 against the euro on July 20, at the height of tourist season. European airlines lost luggage at a record-setting pace in June, with 19 of every 1,000 bags “delayed,” according to the Association of European Airlines. And if that’s not enough, I have just one word for you: Heathrow.

Lesson learned: On second thought, maybe we don’t have it so bad after all.

The roads may be safer than ever, but mind the bridges. This summer, we learned that the nation’s highways have never been safer. The Transportation Department reported the lowest highway fatality rate ever recorded in 2006 and the largest drop in total deaths in 15 years. That came as welcome news to summer travelers, most of whom get to their vacations by car.

But then the I-35W bridge over the Mississippi collapsed in Minneapolis Aug. 1 and the safety statistics didn’t seem relevant — particularly to the motorists who survived and the families of those who didn’t.

Lesson learned: Travel is risky, no matter how you get there.

The “s” in TSA doesn’t stand for security. It was some summer for the Transportation Security Administration. When the federal agency wasn’t busy busting toddlers for carrying unauthorized sippy cups through a checkpoint or stopping four-year-old “terrorists” from boarding a flight, it was issuing indecipherable press releases, like this one about its latest Secure Flight initiative, in an apparent effort to bore would-be hijackers into surrender.

Most passengers couldn’t be bothered by the implications of Secure Flight or know there was a 9/11 commission, but for those who do care, it basically means the end of our civil liberties as we know them. Oh, but what do I know? Maybe it just means we’ll be hassled even more when we try to board a plane.

Lesson learned: None.

It takes more than high gas prices to ruin a vacation. Remember all the talk about $4-a-gallon gas prices that awaited us last summer? At least one survey by PricewaterhouseCoopers predicted disastrous implications on the American vacation, specifically on the hotel industry. That was back in early June, and fuel prices have taken a sharp downturn since then, tumbling from a peak of around $3.20 per gallon to around $2.80.

We’ll never know if the analysts were right because the price of gas headed south. Oh sure, they were annoyed by it — the Access America survey singled out fuel prices as the No. 1 travel annoyance this summer, with about 8 in 10 travelers complaining about them. But in conversations I’ve had with vacationers, it was obvious that they weren’t going to let gas prices get in their way of having a good time. Maybe they would stay with friends instead of checking into a hotel, but by golly, they were going to take their hard-earned three days of vacation.

Lesson learned: “Green travel” is a great idea, as long as it doesn’t interfere with your vacation.

The weather is a great excuse for … anything. This summer seemed to be a continuous meteorological event, from storms that stranded tens of thousands of airline passengers on runways to Hurricane Dean. Travelers know how unpredictable the weather can be, but this summer they also learned that travel companies — especially airlines — love to invoke weather as an excuse for their shortcomings.

So you were stuck on a plane for eight hours without food or water? Blame the weather. Missed your connection? It’s the weather. Flight canceled? Weather!

It is often impossible to prove the weather, or what the travel industry likes to call an “Act of God” — had anything to do with your trip interruption. So when a travel company pulls the weather card, you almost have to become an amateur meteorologist to prove them wrong and get them to take responsibility for your ruined vacation.

Lesson learned: When your airline blames the weather, question it.

I’d like to be optimistic about next summer, but every time I try, the words of reader Stephen Doggette haunt me: “This will all get worse before it ever gets better.”

Christopher Elliott is the author of Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals. Critics have called it “eye-opening” and “inspiring” — it’ll “grab your attention and won’t let go.” Order your copy now on Amazon, Barnes & Noble or iTunes.

1 comment

  • Joe F.

    I will recall one very funny story about weather. The one and only time I actually sued an airline for a missed hotel room was when they claimed there was a weather delay, and both the departure airport, connection airport, place the airplane was coming from and the destination were clear. When I arrived at the airport, there was a thunderstorm over it which cleared by the time the inbound flight to take me to my connection city arrived. There was no delay – the inbound arrived within 15 minutes of schedule.

    When I arrived at my connection city – it was late and naturally I was on the last flight to the destination. Surprisingly there were only 5 [Five] people waiting for this flight. The flight was canceled due to weather. Mind you – the airplane was present, the crew was present and the destination was VFR weather. [This was in 2004 when there still were empty legs occasionally - notably this airline has joined the dodo bird in extinction]

    They refused to compensate anyone. ‘Weather’ was the cause and thats all they said – there was some mumbling about the bad weather in the northeast earlier that day but no specifics. I asked to be Rule 240′d and they nope, not because of ‘weather.’ I had my suspicions so I took down everyone’s name and then took down the FAA ID and airline ship number of the airplane actually sitting at the departure gate. I made a reservation at a local hotel, got a room on the concierge floor, and took away my boarding card for a mid-morning flight the next day.

    When I got home, being a lawyer, I spent $110 and sued them in Superior Court [not small claims] for the cost of the hotel room, the cost of my ticket, and for the lost hotel room at my destination. Their in-house lawyers were rather short with me, and refused to even discuss the matter, again, claiming their records showed it was a weather cancellation and they filed a motion to dismiss based on that. They were not very good lawyers since any lawyer knows if you add your own facts, it is a motion for summary judgment, but you do not need a legal education to appreciate the story.

    I responded to the airline motion asking for the following documents:

    The list of flights canceled that day for any reason, including weather;
    The passenger manifest for that flight, and the return the following morning;
    The maintenance logs for airframe, engine and appliances for the aircraft scheduled for my flight;
    The MEL and Squawk list for the aircraft scheduled for my flight;

    then I asked what are called interrogatories, or questions, to be answered under oath, these included:

    State the reason for the cancellation of Flight XXX on date YYY;
    Identify the person or persons who authorized the flight be canceled;
    Identify the gate number for the flight #XXX from AAA to BBB on that day;
    Identify the crew members assigned to Flight XXX on date YYY;
    Identify the weather conditions which caused the cancellation of flight XXX on date YYY.
    State the weather conditions at the inbound airport where the aircraft assigned to flight XXX on date YYY was scheduled to arrive from,

    You can imagine what happened. The operations department needed to answer the rogs. I actually got the documents before I received a motion to quash the interrogatories from a local law firm whom I knew. The documents showed there were 22 people with reservations on the flight I was on, and only 5 showed up. There were then 32 people with reservations on the outbound the next morning. My suspicions were proven essentially, which was that they canceled the flight due to a microscopic load factor and told the 5 people to screw off essentially. There were several other flights canceled that day – some for mechanical reasons, some for weather, where there was actually weather.

    The lawyers then called me up and said that they were looking to settle when the court ordered their client to answer the questions. When we got done, I got a check for both hotel rooms, for the court filing fees, service fees and my entire air ticket refunded to my credit card. For keeping my mouth shut about their violation of federal law, I got 250,000 miles on an airline they had a Frequent Flier tie in – along with $2500 in vouchers which I promptly used or gave to family to use since they were headed for Chapter 11 in short order. They are now gone and there is no one to sue me for violating the settlement agreement – but – I just used the last of the miles to get an upgrade to business class from the east coast to Beijing. I cannot imagine sitting in coach for 13 hours.

    I guess the answers to the questions would have proved why they canceled the flight. And it was not for weather.

Previous post:

Next post: