When travelers experience discrimination

By | February 21st, 2010

As self-described “adventurous grandparents,” Trevor and Jean Broome had been looking forward to their upcoming trip to Costa Rica, which included diving, hiking, snorkeling and whitewater rafting.

Until they got some bad news from their tour operator: They were too old for the tour they had selected.

Gap Adventures of Toronto recently notified the couple that the adventure package they had purchased had been “re-aligned” to a younger demographic that would “likely be in the 18 to 39 age range.”

To travel is to be discriminated against, of course. Separating passengers and guests by age, income or gender is hardly new; whether it should be happening is an ongoing debate that some travelers seem to be having with greater frequency.

Although a Gap representative told the 50-something Broomes that they could either cancel the tour or continue as planned, Trevor, a retired police officer from Plymouth, England, told me that he was “horrified and deeply offended by this blatant ageism.” He called Gap’s decision to change its tours prejudicial, discriminatory and something done with “total disregard to our feelings.” He added, “Is this any less offensive than discrimination on grounds of race or gender?”

I asked Gap about Broome’s grievance. Lyndon File, the company’s manager for customer satisfaction and safety, said that segmenting tours by age is a common practice in his industry and that the company made every effort to accommodate Broome when it decided to rebrand his Costa Rica tour, including moving him to a different tour with a financial incentive to do so.

“Further, in subsequent e-mail communication with Mr. Broome, I offered to reimburse for any out-of-pocket expenses should he cancel,” he said. “All of these options are fair and reasonable, I believe.”

Related story:   Travelers, be wary of 'data passing' online

It’s difficult to find any real data on discrimination in the travel industry. Perhaps the most reliable numbers come from the airlines.

The Transportation Department reports complaints against carriers every month, and discrimination-related grievances hardly registered (they came in 10th place in the latest month for which statistics were available, behind baggage, customer service and refund-related problems). Are the numbers low because people don’t know they can complain to the DOT, because they don’t bother, or because there’s nothing to complain about? I’ll have the answer in a future column.

Not all of the discrimination is blatant. Consider Dan Nainan, a 28-year-old voice-over artist and comedian from New York, who says that the airline he regularly flies routinely discriminates against him based on his youthful appearance. “Everywhere I go, they challenge me — telling me that the ‘preferred’ line is for first-class passengers only, even though I’m a first-class passenger. They just assume I’m not in first class,” he said. Why? “Because I’m not some fat, gray bald guy with a huge belly wearing a suit and tie.”

But some of the discrimination is overt. Melanie Gutermuth, a disabled veteran and graduate student from Hanover, Md., travels with a service dog. “Most of the time, this is not a problem,” she said. “However, in recent months, that’s changed. People will say, ‘You look normal to me,’ because I’m not in a wheelchair or blind. Consequently, I have been excluded from some services, and charged pet fees for others.”

(Note: Some commenters have suggested that Gutermuth isn’t a veteran, as she claims. I don’t conduct background checks on my sources, but have made a notation that her status as a veteran has been called into question.)

Related story:   The truth about "transparent" airfares

For travelers with disabilities who think that they are being discriminated against, there are places they can turn to for help, according to Kleo King, a senior vice president at the United Spinal Association, a nonprofit organization dedicated to improving the quality of life for people with spinal cord injuries and disorders. She recommends working with a travel agent who specializes in travel for the disabled (you can find one at the Web site Able to Travel and bookmarking pages such as the Department of Justice’s Americans With Disabilities Act site.

C. Welton Gaddy, president of the Interfaith Alliance, suggests that travelers who are discriminated against turn to such groups as the Rights Working Group, an organization that protects civil liberties and human rights for Americans, and the ACLU for more information. Most important, he says, they need to speak up about discrimination.

“If problems occur, either to you or to someone else, be sure to report them immediately and in great detail,” he said. “Using the organization of your choice, seek help in publicizing the discrimination you experienced or witnessed and register the act of discrimination with the appropriate authorities.”

I may be getting ahead of myself — after all, I plan to write about this subject again soon — but I agree that talking about discrimination is certainly the first step to ending it.

I admit I have mixed feelings about this subject. While some kinds of discrimination are unconscionable, others are understandable. No one objects to gender-specific bathrooms, for example. And suggesting that a couple like the Broomes take a less strenuous Costa Rica tour is no crime, in my book. But both of those are also discriminatory, because they exclude someone. Does that make them wrong?

Related story:   What to do about hotel renovation hassles

Likewise, is it discriminatory to ask an oversize person to buy an extra airline seat? To deny someone a rental car because he or she is under 25? To charge a security deposit on a room when you’re traveling with a pet?

You can debate those questions among yourselves. Meantime, say something when you see discrimination on the road. It’s a good place to start.

(Photo: ladybeames/Flickr Creative Commons)

We want your feedback. Your opinion is important to us. Here's how you can share your thoughts:
  • Send us a letter to the editor. We'll publish your most thoughtful missives in our daily newsletter or in an upcoming post.
  • Leave a message on one of our social networks. We have an active Facebook page, a LinkedIn presence and a Twitter account. Every story on this site is posted on those channels. The conversation ranges from completely unmoderated (Twitter) to moderated (Facebook and LinkedIn).
  • Post a question to our help forums or ask our advocates for a hand through our assistance intake form. Please note that our help forum is not a place for debate. It's there primarily to assist readers with a consumer problem.
  • If you have a news tip or want to report an error or omission, you can email the site publisher directly. You may also contact the post's author directly. Contact information is in the author tagline.