What's the book corporate America doesn't want you to read? Find out now -- or you could get scammed.

US Airways, American top list of most complained-about airlines

December 4, 2007

The latest Air Travel Consumer Report suggests passengers are deeply dissatisfied with airline service. In October, the Transportation Department received 1,096 complaints from consumers about airline service — that’s 74 percent more than the 629 complaints received a year earlier, and 22 percent more than the total of 895 filed last month.

Here are the top (or should I say, bottom?) five airlines:

1. US Airways (122 complaints )
2. American Airlines (115 complaints)
3. United Airlines and Delta Air Lines (both had 113 complaints)
4. Northwest Airlines (49 complaints)
5. Continental Airlines (46 complaints)

How do you explain the huge gap between Northwest, Continental and the others? I’m told that some airlines have aggressively begun disputing each official complaint with the DOT. The strategy is to either persuade the government that the complaint doesn’t belong on the airlines’ record, or to have to reassigned to a regional carrier.

So, for example, if I flew on a Northwest flight that had a Pinnacle segment and complained about a service-related problem, the airline might argue to have the complaint reassigned to Pinnacle — a number that travel watchdogs pay little attention to.

The DOT needs to close that loophole, because it allows the airlines to downplay the actual number of complaints.

And here’s a little-known fact, as you review these complaint figures: They represent less than 10 percent of the legitimate complaints against an airline, according to internal airline sources.

The actual number far higher — and far more alarming.

Christopher Elliott is the author of Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals. Critics have called it “eye-opening” and “inspiring” — it’ll “grab your attention and won’t let go.” Order your copy now on Amazon, Barnes & Noble or iTunes.

11 comments

  • MrBadExample

    US Airways at the top of the list?? OHHHHH The pain, the shock of it all!!!

  • Michael Senio

    Q. What kind of complaints are customers making about USAirways? It makes no sense to say that they get the most complaints without telling us what kinds of complaints. I fly USAirways most of the time (out of Binghamton, NY, USAir probably has 70% of the market) and although I have my gripes, they are no more than my gripes with American, United, or Northwestern. How about putting some meat into these kinds of reports? Thanks, Mike Senio

  • Ruben Olivares

    A few month ago you published on a MSNBC segment a list of contacts for airlines in case someone needed to make an issue known. The airline’s web sites have dedicated to hiding all that information restricting a passenger to 1500 characters and not knowing if the message will be received or not.
    Please help if at all possible. Thanks and Regards,

    Ruben Olivares

  • Christopher Elliott
  • MrBadExample

    The Department of Transportation (DOT) has a lovely little form to fill out. It’s one of the ways you can fight back.

  • http://Lleichtman.org Lawrence Leichtman

    I fly a lot 2-3 round trips monthly. Mainly I fly American, US Air and Southwest. By far US Air is the worst. The surliest work crews, the dirtiest planes and oh by the way luggage lost twice this year alone, once not found until the business trip was over. American can definitely run a close second because they typically fly ancient planes and are often late but so far in the last 8 years no luggage lost. Southwest gets my votes for always flying larger planes, friendly service better on time and no lost luggage. The downside they don’t fly everywhere and long trips often require 3 segments instead of 2.

  • Ginger P.

    I have a specific complaint for US Airways: scabies. I just got it, and my research says I am not the first.

  • D Smith

    US Airways Express, two flights 6 months apart, same flight, same time, both flights were 3-4 hours late, leaving my wife and I to run through terminals or stand in long lines to get subsequent connecting flights. First time was due to a single safety card being missing. A mechanic had to be called out of bed(5 AM) to inspect the plane and give the OK to fly. Second time due to no pilot to fly the plane (aircraft and First Officer present), and equipment problems delaying backup flight. Difficult to recommend US Air.

  • GA Reece

    I took a trip from Indianapolis to Gulfport MS. I had to change planes in CLT . Get a seat with more leg room that was $5.00 charge on one flight and $20.00 for one checked bag. I was supposed has to assisance to take me from one flight to the next. NO One show up. I ended having to buy a one day pass into the US AiR Club to rest back, that I have problems with.
    The one broard crew were rude and unfriendly.
    I have American just as bad. the same poor service

  • Lou

    I was seated in Row 24 Seat E. Just before the plane reached cruising altitude I got up to go to the lavatory, which was one row back. I was met by the flight attendant who advised me that I could not and must return to my seat, because the fasten seat belt light was one. She gave me no choice and no warning, but merely in a very loud voice, so that at least 3 rows could hear, that I return to my seat. Another passenger, who I later learned was a USAirways employee informed me that the flight attendant acted in a rude and improper manner. I asked another flight attendant, Verna, if she could give me the name of the rude flight attendant, which name she muttered, but which I could not understand. I asked if she could please get me the name of the rude flight attendant from the rude flight attendant, but Verna refused. The rude flight attendant (who was of Asian ethnicity) remained in the back galley and did not come out to give me her name. In fact, being one of the last passengers off of the plane, I noticed she never did appear from behind the galley. I later learned that this same rude flight attendant refused to provide a pregnant passenger with ice to ease her nausea. She told that passenger that she had locked away the ice. Another passenger, who I learned was furloughed by USAirways was aghast at how rude the flight attendant was and how Verna chose to protect her rude colleague, rather than to uphold customer service. Moreover, when my wife and I came out of the airplane the flight crew were not to be found, so I was unable to discuss my displeasure with the pilot or copilot. The flight was an awful experience and because of the rude flight attendant, Verna and the absence of the flight crew, I would make USAirways the last choice for air travel. Give me Southwest Airlines any day over USAirways. The USAirways bankruptcy case should have been a liquidating case and the executive management fired, as the apparent prevailing corporate attitude and policies are reflected in the crew of Flight 603 – the rude flight attendant, Verna and the captain and his crew!

  • Lauren Turley

    My daughter took a US Airways flight 2502 out of Charlotte, NC to Greenville, NC. on 11-26-2011. They were told by the flight crew that the flight was canciled an hour before they were to leave and gave the reason as weather.  I was at home and found out from the airlines that the flight crew arrived late and the flight was only going to be delayed by 15 minutes.  The flight crew told the passengers they could either rent a car or take the bus.  I told my daughter to stay right there and wait for the flight to leave 15 minutes late.  There were several people who left to find other ways to get home.  For the people that left that was a 4 hour drive.  It is a shame that a company of that size would have employees that would lie to those passengers like that.  I will never fly with US airways and would discourage anyone else from flying with them.  If enough people did that maybe the airline will go under and someone else will take over.  Lauren Turley

Previous post:

Next post: