The mystery of bait-and-switch airfares

John Angarano isn’t just tired of bait-and-switch airfares. He’s also skeptical about the excuses airlines and online booking sites give for displaying an initial low price then switching it out later with a higher fare.

When he recently searched online for a flight from Rochester, N.Y., to Boston, he says he found several affordable prices. Then he received a “this fare is no longer available” error. It happened over and over, he says, before he found a flight he wanted.

“It’s frustrating to get this message and feel like the initial price you saw really isn’t real-time or accurate,” says Angarano, who, as an IT specialist at the University of Rochester Medical Center, is something of an expert on technology.

Are bait-and-switch airfares intentional?

Airline experts and people familiar with airline reservations systems claim it’s not intentional. Rather, it’s the result of caching, or temporarily storing information on a website. That allows prices to be retrieved faster, but makes them a little less accurate. So when a customer tries to book a ticket, they sometimes see a “price has changed” or “ticket unavailable” error message.

It’s a radioactive topic in the airline industry. I reached out to several airline law experts, and all of them refused to comment on the record. But while they may be reluctant to talk, passengers aren’t. Travelers are only too willing to detail their frustrations with now-you-see-them-now-you-don’t fares.

Ella Nusenbaum, a business student from Richmond Hill, Ontario, says she often runs into this kind of pricing on airline and online booking sites. One incident stands out — a flight initially advertised at $1,500.

Related story:   Even smart travelers do stupid things

“In the confirmation window, it suddenly told me that my flight’s price went up to $2,600,” she recalls. “I suspect their system understood my city and dates were firm and decided to push a higher price on me, knowing that I had to book the trip.”

What’s behind the bait-and-switch airfares?

Airlines and agencies have long denied that they leverage customer data to display an initial low fare then switch it out with a higher price once they know you’re interested in buying a ticket. It’s difficult to prove or disprove. It would probably take a lawsuit, a government investigation and an IT audit to determine whether the phenomenon is intentional.

“It’s an unfair practice,” says Amena Tareen, an occupational therapist from Marietta, Ga., who says the fare increase has happened to her “many times.”

“The price usually goes up by $20 to $60, with a message stating the fare is no longer available,” she says.

Before online booking sites, this wasn’t a problem. Travel agents used a reservation system such as Worldspan or Sabre that displayed real-time fares, for the most part. Human agents, who still rely on these systems, say they don’t count on a fare unless they see it on their screens.

“I never quote anything to a client until I can confirm it in Worldspan,” says Becky McGuire, an independent travel agent from Lake Havasu City, Ariz. “If a fare is no longer available, then it should be pulled from the system.”

What’s at stake?

It’s difficult to estimate the additional revenue generated by changing fares. Domestic airlines earned $91.2 billion from fares in 2016 according to U.S. Department of Transportation data. That’s about 73 percent of the industry’s total annual operating revenue from domestic operations. Airlines sold about 719 million domestic tickets.

Related story:   Maybe they should blame your next flight delay on space aliens

Assuming every other passenger paid just $10 more than expected because of these tactics, then airlines reaped a cool $7 billion from bait-and-switch airfares in 2016, or about 6 percent of their domestic ticket revenue.

“It’s not that hard to refresh Web pages to prevent having outraged consumers,” says Eric Johnson, a professor at the Columbia Business School who recently published a paper on how consumers react when they encounter hidden fees.

And if airline executives and booking sites think their customers will grow accustomed to this kind of pricing, his research suggests the opposite. Over the long term, it could drive customers away.

“While economists think a price is a price, behavioral science thinks the way the price is portrayed makes a difference,” Johnson says. “The problem is that when that price is not available, people react to the pain of the increase plus the pain of the original price.”

No smoking gun on bait-and-switch airfares

The Department of Transportation (DOT), which regulates airfares, has a full-fare advertising rule that prohibits carriers and ticket agents from utilizing bait-and-switch methods. For example, it’s illegal to advertise a low fare at the beginning of the ticketing process only to present the consumer with a higher fare at the end.

I checked with DOT spokeswoman Caitlin Harvey, and she said the agency was aware of the complaints about alleged bait-and-switch airfares. But to bring any enforcement action, the agency would need proof of an airline “systematically and intentionally” using this tactic to lure consumers to its website or increasing the prices ultimately paid by passengers.

Related story:   Seriously? Poll finds car rental companies have the most surprise fees

Put differently, there’s no smoking gun. And until there is, nothing is likely to change.

That’s wrong, says Paul Hudson, president of FlyersRights.org, an organization that advocates for air travelers. “It is not up to the consumer to prove that an airline is engaging in bait-and-switch tactics,” he says.

For passengers, the takeaway is dead simple: Don’t always believe what you see when you’re shopping for airline tickets.

Bait-and-switch airfares are:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Christopher Elliott

Christopher Elliott is an author, journalist and consumer advocate. You can read more about him on his personal website or check out his adventures on his family adventure travel site. Contact him at chris@elliott.org. Read more of Christopher's articles here.

%d bloggers like this:
Get smart. Sign up for the newsletter.