What's the book corporate America doesn't want you to read? Find out now -- or you could get scammed.

Carnival’s Norwalk deaths?

November 25, 2006

Here’s a question that is raised far too infrequently: Can the Norwalk virus — an increasingly common shipboard affliction — kill passengers?

That’s what one Tarpon Springs, Fla., family is asking after their father, David Lee Fitzgerald, died on a recent Carnival cruise.

It is also something medical examiners in Broward County are pondering. Fitzgerald, it turns out, isn’t the only passenger who died during the Norwalk virus outbreak that afflicted 679 passengers on the Carnival Liberty. Another man, who was identified only as a non-US citizen, also perished.

We won’t know the answer for a while. Dr. Joshua Perper, Broward County’s chief medical examiner, said it will take several months to complete lab tests and determine an official cause of death. I will be watching, as will be other concerned travel bloggers.

But back to the question at hand. Can Norwalk kill?

Yes, it turns out that it can. And does.

The Centers for Disease Control recently analyzed data from nearly 40 outbreaks over a period of about a decade, and found that 7.5 in every 10,000 cases was fatal. The hospitalization rate was about 33 in 10,000 — meaning that if you’re unlucky enough to be sent to the infirmary for the Norwalk virus, you have a 1 in 4 chance of dying.

I guess there’s something to be said for keeping a clean ship.

Christopher Elliott is the author of Scammed: How to Save Your Money and Find Better Service in a World of Schemes, Swindles, and Shady Deals. Critics have called it “eye-opening” and “inspiring” — it’ll “grab your attention and won’t let go.” Order your copy now on Amazon, Barnes & Noble or iTunes.

2 comments

  • Albert O’Connor

    40 outbreaks in 10 years? Were those only on cruise ships? How many outbreaks were in nursing homes? Hospitals? All inclusive hotels? What about Legionaries (sic?) We also don’t know how many folks went home with it, how many brought it with them,or picked it up on a port call. Much like the flu, wash your hands Please!

  • C. Blizzard

    Hi Christopher,

    I just returned from a long vacation and read your story about the ill-fated Carnival Liberty, TransAtlantic Cruise, November 3-19, 2006.

    I was on that cruise and fortunately did not get sick. However, I did not notice anything the ship did which jeopardized the health of passengers or crew.

    On the other hand, I noticed many of my fellow cruisers displaying poor hygeine habits. People were coughing and sneezing without attempting to cover their mouths or otherwise restricting the flow of their germs. I also observed people who went out of their way to avoid the hand sanitizing dispensers, which were numerous. I even saw one person pick up his table napkin, blow his nose and toss the thing back on the table.

    I have been on 21 cruises and I agree with you in not liking a dirty ship; however, I have never been on a ship where so many people displayed such poor health habits.

    I also provided this information to the CDC personnel on board the Liberty. Please feel free to quote me or contact me if you have questions regarding my experiences on the ship. I really hate to see the cruiseline get undeserved bad press.

    Happy New Year.

Previous post:

Next post: