Airline complaints surge 37 percent in latest report; US Airways is most complained about carrier

January 3, 2008

Complain, complain, complain. Is that all airline passengers can do?

Even though domestic carriers had fewer flight delays, cancellations and mishandled bags this past November than during the same month a year before, customers didn’t take notice, according to the Transportation Department’s latest Air Travel Consumer Report.

Gripes about airline service mushroomed by 37 percent for the month, with the government receiving 808 grievances from consumers about airline service, 37 percent more than the 589 complaints received in November 2006.

The five most complained about airlines for November are:

1. US Airways (101 complaints)
2. American Airlines (92 complaints)
3. United Airlines (88 complaints)
4. Delta Air Lines (78 complaints)
5. Northwest Airlines (42 complaints)

What’s up with Northwest? Its numbers were more than twice Southwest’s (20 complaints) but still far below the other legacy carriers’, except Continental (33 complaints). I suspect its latest customer service initiative is sticking. Good.

✓ Get the latest travel news, tips and commentary from Elliott’s E-Mail, the subversive newsletter from industry gadfly Christopher Elliott. You’ll travel like a pro. Sign up here. It’s free.

Similar Posts:

24 comments

{ 24 comments… read them below or add one }

Jesse January 3, 2008 at 1:32 pm

$1.00 per leg anyone?

Jasper January 3, 2008 at 4:32 pm

@ Jesse: Airlines would probably charge you a $12.47 charging/convenience/collection fee to get that $1. You might not know that administring all these charges and fees is very expensive (when they do not benefit the airlines themselves).

Jesse January 3, 2008 at 5:17 pm

Jasper,

I don’t disagree with what you are saying, I have no idea what the cost they will try to administer will be, however, if it is a mandated fee the government imposes onto the airlines, I believe it would be different. Am I mistaken? (Yeah, you never know what will happen with the gvmt)

Let’s just throw it around…maybe??

Douglas Muth January 4, 2008 at 10:26 am

Say, how do we file a complaint of our own?

I actually had a pretty bad experience with US Airways just last weekend (sat on the runway for over an hour), and I would love to add my name to the list of complainants.

Thanks,

– Doug

Christopher Elliott January 4, 2008 at 10:55 am
dan Ross January 4, 2008 at 1:57 pm

You only get what you pay for.

Ron January 7, 2008 at 9:25 pm

I’ve been a long time customer of US Airways simply because, as a resident of Pittsburgh, I’ve been forced to!

There are certainly two sides to this coin; the employees of US Airways have been put through hell over the past ten years, with an almost endless series of pay cuts, retrenchments, labor disputes, etc.. They have many reasons to be bitter and angry.

On the other hand, as a customer, I really don’t care. You may not like your job or your boss or your company, but you can’t (as a professional) let it seep into everything you do.

I was on a SWA flght to Midway over Christmas. It was one of the most turbulent flights I’ve ever been on…and yet the crew managed to keep everyone laughing and calm. “Just a helpful reminder, there are barf bags behind every seat!”

If the airlines want to win us over, they should remember that; “keep ‘em laughing!” Maybe the SWA crew had taken those comedy/improv lessons that Second City gives!

Kitty January 8, 2008 at 12:36 am

My husband and I had an ‘interesting’ trip home with US Airways, from visiting family.

We knew what to expect, flying the day after Christmas. However, even our patience was tested. Our seats were taken hostage by children. Stewardess’s attempted to seat us apart in other seats, but acted like we were being difficult when we insisted we stay together. While waiting on new seats, we stood in the back area, where the carpet was soaked with soda.

Of course, there were “new” parents with an infant in the seat behind us who had no idea how to quiet the baby (it IS possible, people!!). Both food AND drinks ran out before they got to us at the back of the plane (all they had left was alcohol). When the plane finally took off (an hour late), it sounded like it would literally fall apart. After being ignored, screamed at, left hungry and with sticky shoes for 6 hours, finally we made it home.

Every year we swear not to travel at Christmas… maybe this time we’ll remember our oath next year.

gordy mckelvey January 20, 2008 at 9:25 pm

37% of what? Simple math would shed some interesting light on these reported numbers. I’m not a fan of any of the airlines. I think they all charge way too much and have had favorable legislation through out the years to give them the upper hand when it comes to dealing with customers. However, take the US Air figures. Divide the number of passengers that flew on US Air in the month of November, into the 101 complaints. The resulting answer will have so many zeros to the right of the decimal point that what you have is an insignificant percentage. Complain on! If you have time to spare, go by air!

David January 20, 2008 at 11:20 pm

last time I traveled US AIR, was a puddle jumper between Miami and Key West. They offered “Limited Service” which meant I could have a Coke, or NOTHING. I’m Diabetic, and explained that to the attendant. She said Too Bad we only have Coke. No diet. I complained to the website, never even got a “sorry” reply. I’ll never fly them again.

Mac January 21, 2008 at 12:12 am

If the American Public would stop searching for $50.00 seats, we would get better planes, employees, and service. Problem is, your “bargain” seat tossed my enjoyable flight out the window. I am not saying that airlines are not to blame for much of this, but we as consumers want the best for the least, and its not gonna happen.
If you cannot afford to fly, take your car. If you are going to fly obey the rules and regs, show up on time, wear appropriate clothing. Be respectful to the employees you expect respect from. Being a demanding bitch with ill behaved children, or travelling intoxicated is unacceptable. I might just be the man in the seat behind you, that stands up and puts you in your place, for the sake of the rest of us.

Linda January 21, 2008 at 12:32 am

We flew last year to Cabo and our return flight we used US Airways,what a stressful vacation. First we were delayed in Cabo for takeoff and then arriving in Phoenix heading for customs it got worse. They were not prepared for that many passengers and told us to leave our baggage and head to the gate and they would hold for all us which was approximately 20 people. We finally get through the passport check point and run for the TSA check point and we are stall again. Then onto the gate which is at the other side and they announce we have ten minutes, we make it to the gate and they tell us we can’t get on because they closed the doors. We ask for our bags which they politely tell us we can’t have them and that we will not be able to get out for three days because they are booked. Mind you, she was totally rude and would not help any us and told us to go to customer service, end of story. We will never fly US Airways or as we say US Scare. Long Story short they did nothing to help any us and basically told us we were on our own. Great Customer Service. Not to mention leaving all of the baggage unintended. Great Security.

susan January 24, 2008 at 10:32 am

I am a former employee of US Airways who left the company in December 2004 after 27 years of service. During those years I was a customer service employee and a member of a union and for the last half of my career a member of mid-level management who worked closely with the unions and top executives of the company. US Airways’ history is liittered with golden parachutes given to executives who were brought into the company to revive what was once three separate, great airlines; USAir, PSA, and Piedmont. It goes without saying that none of them achieved the goal for the airline but did pad their own pockets with money they never truly earned at the expense of all the employees and the loyal customers of the airline. It breaks my heart to see reports ranking USAirways at the top in customer complaints. As you fly this beleaguered carrier, please try to focus more on the employee who is doing a good job. The majority of these employees have been through the “ring of fire” and are working twice as hard for half the wages they received just 7 years ago but worse they have far fewer tools to do their jobs. I summoned the courage to leave my airline career after realizing it was a continual spiral downward, but not all are in a position to make such a change. US Airways is really a “tale of two cities”, look at the opulent lifestyles of former CEO’s and executives since the 1990’s who have left the company worse off than they found it and then look at the dedicated employee who still strive everyday to keep the airline afloat and worry how they will pay their mortgages. It is indeed a very sad story.

HLMcD January 24, 2008 at 12:48 pm

Dear David “Diabetic” Puddle Jumper from Miami to Key West…

David…get serious….a jump from Miami to Key West was maybe, at best 20 minutes or so….ok, an hour between boarding and disembarking….and you are complaining about no food? You are a diabetic and expecting to be fed on a puddlejumper? Please! Carry a snack with you, or break down and buy a sandwich at the airport, or better yet, make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich to take with you.

I am so tired of hearing you sniveling diabetics whine about “I’m a diabetic and I haven’t eaten all day”. Diabetics arriving “so sick” they had to take an ambulance to my Emergency Department. What’s the first thing they say when they are unloaded from the paramedic gurney into the ER room, “I’m a diabetic and I haven’t eaten all day”….”I need to have something to eat, I’m a diabetic”….

Gads, get a life. You KNOW you are a diabetic, plan accordingly and please, shut up and quit your whining!!!!! You’re probably morbidly obese anyway and missing a meal would be a plus!!!

Ricardo January 24, 2008 at 1:24 pm

Complain Complain Complain. You DON’T have to fly. Catch the bus. Ride a train. If you are aware of things that go on in the world in which you live, you would know why there is so much trouble at most of these airlines. You get what you pay for. They don’t want to pay their workers, have forced pay cuts on them, fuel is off the chart, and did you forget what 911 caused? I don’t see Continental Airlines on that list. The only thing you have to buy on Continental is alcohol and headsets. If you have your own headset you can watch the movie for free! They don’t charge for food and soft drinks. And even if they did. You could BUY OR BRING YOUR OWN FOOD. Its true those USAirways stories are bad, but their are better choices out there

linda giffiths January 24, 2008 at 1:51 pm

northwest airlines has no customer service,and as far as getting what you pay for,paid 1500.00 for round trip ticket from lax to aberdeen,sd ,flight from aberdeen was cancelled 4 times on returning flight,never was offered any compensation for delay,people were rude at ticketing,will never fly them again,and will tell all my friends never to use them also.

Fritz February 1, 2008 at 3:56 pm

Hello,

On January 13, 2008, I was scheduled to fly from Washington Reagan National to Burlington, Vermont on US Air Flight 3226, leaving at 9:10 pm. On that date, a snowstorm passed through the Phila/NYC/Boston area; the storm did not affect the Burlington airport approach conditions or the runways, which were dry at the time of our scheduled departure with no change until the following afternoon. I have a record of the weather to that effect. The planes flying this route are usually smaller jets, but they rolled a larger plane to the gate and eventually boarded us at 10:45 pm and shut the cabin door, only to announce at about 11:20 that the flight was canceled due to “weather”. One surly customer service person met the offloaded passengers and proved to everyone as she plodded through each passenger’s sad story that she was far more inconvenienced than we were. I left without taking her valuable time and found a room at a nearby hotel, called my wife to advise her of the situation, confirmed the weather conditions & forecast with her and made my reservations for the next day’s flight.

The next day, a US Air employee (we have his name and number) advised a few of us that our flight the night before had been cancelled because the larger plane was needed elsewhere in the system the following morning.

Later that week, I applied for a reimbursement of expenses (about $220) for the hotel room and one meal. The e-mailed response from “customer relations” on January 16 was that “…Deteriorated weather conditions made flying to Burlington an impossibility. It became apparent an improvement in this situation was not going to happen…the flight was cancelled for safety reasons.” Actually, the approach and field conditions at BTV on January 14, when I finally did arrive on a smaller, fully-loaded US Air Flt 3226, were considerably worse – low ceiling, limited visibility, wet runways and taxiways.

My loss was $220 and a day’s work, but that must be multiplied by the number of souls on the January 13 flight. US Air prevaricated itself out of a considerable amount of cash solely for its own convenience.

As I read the various complaints written in blogs and on other websites, I am convinced as are many others that US Air and others predictably violates its “Customer Service Plan”, (http://www.usairways.com/awa/content/aboutus/customersfirst/customerserviceplan.aspx) which it claims is the “Customers First” plan, “a joint effort of the airline industry, the US Congress, and the US Department of Transportation”, pertaining to cancellations due to weather vs. administrative/logistical considerations.

Outsourcing agent March 7, 2008 at 10:12 pm

I am a former outsourcing reservations agent for US Airways. I cannot but agree with what they have written about the airline’s managament. Although I worked for Atento Mexico, which provided the service for the airline, I experienced first hand the bad policies of the company. You know them well. What I can contribute with is a picture of what outsourcing is doing for this company and what this company does with it.

Reservations agents in Mexico, El Salvador, Guatemala and Manila suffer from the overexploitation of the outsourcing companies. They are expected to take one call after the other for hours, sometimes not even being allowed to take a toilet break. When there are not enough calls, they send a number of agents home without payment to “increase productivity”. If you ever complain about it, you are fired.

The average training period for an outsourcing agent to take your calls is two weeks. The airline does not mind as long as they are making profit paying low wages and not having to deal with Unions (another reason to be fired is to seriously talk about organising one). The average schooling of an outsourcing supervisor is High School. Thank God you might never get to talk to one–what you usually get is an agent assigned supervisor calls, who is mostly a middle man between you and an American agent you never get to talk to.

Outsourcing companies’ management is also very corrupt. Agents that reported corruption cases (e.g. Outsourcing supervisors arranging tickets with huge discounts and mileless upgrades taking them away from a paying customer) were always ignored by the airline and let alone to face reprisals.

Whenever a concern on customer service quality arose, US Airways sent a couple of people to check the call centres abroad (which prepared to stage a harmonious atmosphere during their stay), who always came up with higher demands and never cared to check the performance of the outsourcing management or suggested that the airline supervised training directly.

For US Airways, outsourcing call centres are sweat shops and they could not care less about the proper working conditions, training, and management necessary for you to get the customer service you deserve as users of the airline.

Mike E. Bear April 7, 2008 at 12:02 am

OK, we all know USAir has abysmal management. I’d personally love to meet the genius that came up with the “marginal revenue stream” idea of putting those tacky ads on the tray tables (and taking the airphones out). It amazes me that despite the cretinous management, a lot of realy dedicated people still work for the airline.

But I think management crossed the line from merely laughable, tacky and low rent into actual illegal business practices with their new “overweight baggage ambush” policy. If you haven’t experienced it, it goes something like this:

1) Book a deeply discounted economy class ticket. Get the standard contract language about change fees per fare basis etc. Fair enough. No mention of baggage policy.

2) Check in online for your flight. Get a boarding pass, still no mention of baggage policy. If you’re really curious, you can spend a while digging for the “contract of carriage” on the web site. But since it is subject to change up to the moment you board the flight. it is pretty much meaningless. In any event it says something about bags over 50lbs “may be subject to additional charges”. Shrug, OK. Last time somebody weighed my bags was 25 years ago, and it was by the pound for overweight.

3) Get to the airport. WHAMMO. BIG signs everywhere telling you that if any one checked bag weighs over 50lbs, that will be and extra $50 per bag. Surprise!! And it gets better. As of now, you can check two bags, and they can be 50 lbs each for a total of 100lbs of airlift required, at no charge. But check just 1 at 51lbs and cha-ching, that will be $50. Guess math and physics aren’t required for a airline industry MBA anymore.

Clearly this is a scam to rip off the vacation travelers who are flying on deeply discounted advance seats, have zero flexibility in their plans, and are likely loaded up with a bunch of heavy stuff they need to check. Interestingly, there is no mention of what happens if each of your carry ons weighs more than 50 lbs. Technically you could airship 200lbs besides yourself and pay nothing extra if you distributed it over 4 bags. But of course this isn’t about recouping reasonable airlift costs, it’s about a sleazy way of extracting some marginal revenue out of the loss leader fares back in economy.

Oh, and by the way, they don’t always enforce it, so it makes it even harder for the not so frequent traveller to figure out the scam and work around it. Really, really slimy.

I have one of the original USAir Dividend Preferred cards. At this point, after more than 20 years, I won’t be using it or USAir ever again.

joe creel May 21, 2008 at 7:32 pm

American airlines latest stunt in charging for all checked luggage is outrageous!!Is there NO policing agency to stop the airlines from doing whatever they want to do to make it worse for the traveling public

I think American Airlines might as well come up with a new slogan
How bout….We are going to think of every way we can to screw our customers!!

PAUL EDWARDS November 14, 2008 at 1:31 am

How can an airline like US Airways treat people with no compassion and still get passengers in this day and age of competition? we recently booked 3 return tickets to Florida from Manchester In the united Kingdom as we where having a family get together with people from New Zealand, Unfortunately we got a phone call that the son off the family in New Zealand who was 12 years old had been rushed into hospital and sadly died, we immediately fly from the UK to NZ to be with them (it was my wife’s sisters son) he had had a brain bleed and died almost instantly.

On returning to the UK I contacted US Airways to say we would have to cancel our flights as there would be no family get together under the circumstances, there response was basically sorry for the loss but you have non refundable tickets so you loose £1800 and thank you for using US Airways.

I sent several emails asking them to use some compassion but the last email said it all here it is in full.

Dear Mr. Edwards:

Even though we understand your frustration, when you purchased your ticket, you agreed to the terms and conditions of a non-refundable ticket. We are not able to go beyond those perimeters of a non-refundable ticket, and therefore will close the file.

Sincerely,
Judy Ellefson.
US Airways Customer Relations
Corporate Office

Now even though you should read the terms and conditions most don’t as I didn’t but surely some compassion must come into play?

I will never use US Airways again and as the family concerned have had a full refund from New Zealand Airways feel US Airways are just exploiting the situation.

Yours Faithfully

Paul Edwards

Eileen January 10, 2009 at 8:11 pm

I plan on exposing the scam that US Air perpetrates on their flying public. We had our seating change on all 4 of our flights this past week. We reserved our tickets and seats in July 08. We were separated and given poorly placed seating and told that we could purchase premium seats. This is a scam and is beyond coincidence. I plan on contacting the media and major metropolitan cities (travel sections) about this practice. The traveling public needs to be made aware of this reprehensible practice. Shame on you US Air. As an earlier post mention, the not so frequent traveler of US Air may not notice this scam.

Jen April 18, 2009 at 2:21 pm

US Airways has proved to be the most awful airline currently flying. My husband and I travel a lot – as in 4-6 flights per week. We have been flying US Airways for most of those flights in the past couple of years. We have almost never redeemed miles for free flights however, this week, our 17 year old daughter had the opportunity to intern with a film production company in LA so we redeemed miles to fly her out. A couple of days ago, we learned the production is going to wrap early so called to change our daughter’s return flight. 2 days and 4 attempts later, my husband finally got a supervisor named Carmen on the phone. He was polite but firm about what he wanted her to do. Carmen said she could call someone about releasing a seat on an earlier flight but would only do so if we agreed to pay $150.00. My husband asked if she would make the call and see if they would accept miles instead. He made it clear that he would pay cash if necessary but wanted Carmen to see if it was possible to use miles. She refused. When my husband reminded her that we are talking about arrangements for a minor child traveling alone and that he just wanted her to make the call and ask, she again flatly refused to even try. My husband was stunned and told her he had never been treated like this by any other airline and for as often as we travel US Air, he didn’t think a phone call was too much to ask. Carmen’s response: “Than call another airline. Thanks for calling US Air!” and she hung up.
Thank you US Air for stranding my 17 year old child who grew up in a very small town by herself in the city of Los Angeles. She is scared and we are panicking trying to find her another flight home.

Amy October 20, 2009 at 11:29 pm

NPR just had a piece on the outsourcing of US Air for their mechanical work to El Salvador. It was noted that critical errors were made-wires crisscrossed and going to the wrong engine-so if one engine fails you mistakenly shut off the good engine. How frightening is that? US Air should not be in business. It is too risky to fly with them.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: