5 outrageous luggage fee myths the airlines want you to believe

By | August 4th, 2009

luggageHas the airline industry won the luggage fee war?

Consider the following facts:

• Airlines earned $566 million from checked baggage fees in the first quarter, according to the Bureau of Transportation Statistics. That’s more than four times as much as it collected for the same period a year before.

• Air carriers have publicly declared that passengers accept the fees. Only a few brave travel pundits are challenging those claims, but it appears no one is listening to them.

• Far from backing down, airlines are now raising the baggage fees. The latest is American Airlines, which famously introduced the idea of a $15 fee for the first checked bag. Uh, make that $20.

But a key to this devastatingly successful PR campaign is the mass acceptance of certain statements that aren’t entirely accurate. The airline industry as a whole wants us to embrace the following myths about checked luggage fees:

1. “We need to offset high energy prices.”

That may have swayed some passengers when oil was at $125 a barrel, a price that American Airlines’ chief executive Gerard Arpey complained the industry was “not built to withstand.” But oil is trading at around $70 a barrel today. Not exactly a bargain, but the airline industry is still flying, thanks very much.

2. “You’re only paying for what you use.”

Another flawed argument used by airlines and airline apologists is that the first-bag fee allows travelers to only pay for what they use. Oh really? There are lots of amenities that are considered a part of the airline ticket that don’t get used by every passenger, including a waiting area at the gate, beverage service, restrooms and those compelling in-flight magazines. By that logic, we should begin to “unbundle” those too.

Related story:   Banned for life for being too pretty

3. “If we added a free checked bag, we’d have to raise fares by $15.”

That’s highly unlikely. Remember, none of the airlines lowered their fares by $15 across the board when they added the first checked-bag fee. Fact is, airlines don’t control their fares — we do. Fluctuations of only a few dollars are enough to drive us away — or send us to our computers to book. And airlines know it. If they allowed us to check our first bag at no extra cost, there would be no fare increase.

4. “The government says it’s OK.”

If the government were doing its job, that shouldn’t be true. The Transportation Department has the authority to tell the airlines to stop this a la carte fee nonsense. But because of a pro-business attitude among rank-and-file regulators at the DOT, it isn’t going to budge on luggage fees. Even if it means misrepresenting a few facts along the way.

5. “You don’t want to subsidize someone else’s checked bags.”

That’s an argument I hear from a lot of business travelers who travel with just one carry-on bag: If airlines allowed a “free” checked bag, then those of us who carry only one bag would effectively subsidize the airfares of those who check a bag. That’s patently absurd, considering myth #3, and considering the fact that business travelers already pay fares that are an average of four times higher than leisure travelers. Bag or no bag, they’re subsidizing lower leisure fares. Maybe they should be protesting that instead.

(Photo: conallob/Flickr Creative Commons)

Related story:   "It was the worst airline experience I have ever had"

  • carolm

    I was livid at Trans Air in San Antonio, we flew in with Trans Air from Atlanta, going back, we were told our luggage was 1/2 inch too long! and
    they were going to charge us $49.00!!! We told them we flew in just 2 days ago and was not charge that. I told them that the Trans Air measured it in Atlanta and it went through just fine. But they told us either pay or I could not check in my luggage. I bought another suitcase from a suitcase store across the from Trans Air…mmmm…must be a common practice with Trans Air, the owner at the store gave us a 10 percent discount. I would rather spend a $100 for another suitcase rather than give the airline another dime!

  •  The airlines do, what I refer to as “Feed my crap and tell me how good it tastes.” I obviously cleaned that up a little bit but the airlines continuously keep making up stories to try to convince the air traveler that they are always on the verge of going under and they cannot survive without the changes that they make. I, for one, believe very little that they tell me.

We want your feedback. Your opinion is important to us. Here's how you can share your thoughts:
  • Send us a letter to the editor. We'll publish your most thoughtful missives in our daily newsletter or in an upcoming post.
  • Leave a message on one of our social networks. We have an active Facebook page, a LinkedIn presence and a Twitter account. Every story on this site is posted on those channels. The conversation ranges from completely unmoderated (Twitter) to moderated (Facebook and LinkedIn).
  • Post a question to our help forums or ask our advocates for a hand through our assistance intake form. Please note that our help forum is not a place for debate. It's there primarily to assist readers with a consumer problem.
  • If you have a news tip or want to report an error or omission, you can email the site publisher directly. You may also contact the post's author directly. Contact information is in the author tagline.